Researchers in England examined shame and social anxiety in a cross-sectional sample of people with and without psychosis. They found that social anxiety disorder (SAD) is “surprisingly prevalent among people with psychosis.” The authors suggest that shame cognitions “arising from a stigmatizing illness play a significant role in social anxiety in psychosis.” The article appeared in the FirstView section of Psychological Medicine on May 21, 2012.
Note from Kermit Cole, “In the News” editor:
Of course this study can make no inferences about etiology or causation, being a cross-sectional study, and the question of whether the shame and/or social anxiety pre-existed social anxiety and/or psychosis is open for discussion.
Mad in America hosts blogs by a diverse group of writers. These posts are designed to serve as a public forum for a discussion—broadly speaking—of psychiatry and its treatments. The opinions expressed are the writers’ own.
Mad in America has made some changes to the commenting process. You no longer need to login or create an account on our site to comment. The only information needed is your name, email and comment text. Comments made with an account prior to this change will remain visible on the site.
Researchers are ‘surprised’ that people feel shame and social anxiety after being criminalized by society for having a breakdown and after being foricbly labeled with stigmatizing labels?
Wow, these researchers sound bright!
I thought everybody knew that good, great and wonderful causes shame. *looks around to see who got it*
I think they are overlooking the role of shame in causing a, “Breakdown,” in the first place. Yes, there is stigma that makes things worse, and yes, involuntary treatment and patronising staff who don’t want to know how someone really sees the world or how they came to have the breakdown in the first place can make things a whole lot worse, but I read that shame is a prime driver of extreme states and it seems to be true in many cases.
This kind of breakdown often comes on in early adult hood, when the person is making a transition form teenager to independent adult. they needed more support than they were getting, often due to earlier traumas that have now resulted in them not having the confidence to deal with adult life. The person then feels ashamed for not being able to deal with things, their mental state spirals down and a breakdown results (hearing voices etc). This can all be compounded by the early trauma being perceived as a shameful event.
So I think the paper is only partly right.
Spot on, John, wonderful comment.
the society should feel shame for not giving us a proper help not the other way around
As always with correlation v. causality.
(I think you’ve hit on the crux point.)
Perhaps your unaware of the innate responses, of which shame-humiliation is one, Kermmit?
Soome suggest that shame is the great “social affect,” by which societies form into hierarchical groups of rank & status? Are we suffering from a need to deny our own nature, when we assume that shame belong’s only to “them?”
Consider Tomkins description of nine innate affects, as the root of our emotions and their physiological/psychological manifestations;
These are the nine affects, listed with a low/high intensity label for each affect and accompanied by its biological expression:
* Enjoyment/Joy – smiling, lips wide and out
* Interest/Excitement – eyebrows down, eyes tracking, eyes looking, closer listening
* Surprise/Startle – eyebrows up, eyes blinking
* Anger/Rage – frowning, a clenched jaw, a red face
* Disgust – the lower lip raised and protruded, head forward and down
* Dissmell (reaction to bad smell) – upper lip raised, head pulled back
* Distress/Anguish – crying, rhythmic sobbing, arched eyebrows, mouth lowered
* Fear/Terror – a frozen stare, a pale face, coldness, sweat, erect hair
* Shame/Humiliation – eyes lowered, the head down and averted, blushing
One of Tomkins pupils is Donald L. Nathanson, M.D. A Philadelphia-based psychiatrist with a lifetime interest in the nature of human emotion. Well known for his brilliant understanding of our compass of shame, and how it functions both consciously and unconsciously.
The hit TV show Lie to Me, is based on Tomkins research;
and another of his pupils, Paul Ekman;
Sadly, most people don’t seem to want to know much about this stuff, when their in subconscious need, of unloading an emotional projection. “Its not me, its them!”
Agree 100%, ooo. Society should feel shame for how it treats people who have experienced adverse life conditions and experiences and were not blessed with strong support systems. Its general treatment of such people and situations is inexcusable.