AMI-Quebec Lecture: Rethinking Psychiatry With Robert Whitaker


Last week, Robert Whitaker gave a talk at AMI-Quebec (Action on Mental Illness) entitled Rethinking Psychiatry: How the Failure to Identify the Biological Causes of Major Mental Disorders Opens Up New Possibilities for Long-term Recovery. The talk can be viewed below.

An article in the Montreal Gazette ahead of the talk summarized its major points:

“For decades, the prevailing wisdom was that psychiatric illnesses were diseases of the brain — biological disorders caused by chemical imbalances.

That model was a ‘story of people having a chronic condition, something amiss inside your brain, and the best you could do is take drugs long-term, like with diabetes,’ as award-winning American journalist and author Robert Whitaker told the Montreal Gazette — and recovery meant stabilizing within that model of care.

That model has collapsed.

Despite decades of research, there are no findings to show that people with psychiatric illnesses necessarily suffer from a biological abnormality — and, furthermore, there is no evidence that psychiatric drugs have any long-term benefit, said Whitaker, who has written extensively about psychiatry and the history of psychiatry.

The understanding now is that causes of such conditions as depression, psychosis and mania are varied and include life events and setbacks, trauma and other factors — and that many people suffer an ‘episode’ of an illness that resolves over time. This opens new avenues for promoting a robust recovery from psychiatric disorders, he said.

. . . ‘This crumbling of the old disease model leads to this lovely, optimistic, evidence-based story that, so often, specific difficulties can be episodic in nature, not chronic — and so we need a paradigm of care to address that.’

. . . The way in which drugs shape long-term outcomes must be understood against our natural capacity to recover, he said, ‘and, on the whole, they worsen long-term outcomes.'”


Back to Around the Web


  1. Hi Robert,

    I agree with you. I didn’t benefit much from psychiatric treatments in the early 1980s. But I was able to access alternatives that worked better than the Psychiatric “Medications”.

    The Psychiatrist I was seeing in 1983 offered me the chance to abruptly withdraw from psychiatric drugs, with poor results. And then a very poor Diagnosis of Longterm Schizophrenia.

    I managed after this to successfully reduce the worst of the medications and to return to normal life, as a result. Through the years the rest of the drugs went to one side of their own accord.

    The psychiatric drug exposure between 1980 and 1983 had distorted me, and could have turned me into a long term psychiatric patient.

    Potentially Disabling Anxiety was my biggest Problem. But I was able to find a route out of this, through trial and error.

    The type of Approach that worked for me in the 1980s is also covered by Eckhart Tolle in “The Power Of Now”
    And by
    Psychiatrist Dr David R Hawkins in his self help book “Letting Go”

    [Anxiety is a type of Closed Space that Reinforces itself through the thought process and High Anxiety is Potentially Disabling].

    Report comment