Mental Health Professionals Critique the Biomedical Model of Psychological Problems

8
While a great deal of the excitement about advances in psychological treatments comes from the potential for research in neuroscience to unlock the secrets of the brain, many mental health experts would like to temper this enthusiasm. A special issue of the Behavior Therapist released this month calls into question the predominant conception of mental illnesses as brain disorders.

“Can We Please Stop Pretending Marijuana is Harmless?”

24
“Underscoring the incredible momentum to legalize marijuana is the misconception that the drug can’t hurt anybody,” Dr. Sushrut Jangi writes in the Boston Globe. “It can, especially young people.” He suggests that the biochemistry of marijuana effects "systems ordinarily involved in healthy behaviors like eating, learning and forming relationships” and “throws the finely tuned system off balance.”

“US Opioid Epidemic Fueled by Prescribing Practices”

3
Medscape Psychiatry reports that the “man-made epidemic” of opioid abuse in the United States is the result of over-prescription and poor research.

“NYS Moves to Parity in Mental Health Treatment”

3
New York State has investigated five large insurance companies for violating state and federal mental health parity laws by illegally denying to cover claims for behavioral health conditions and drug abuse treatment, according to a report by North County Public Radio (ncpr).

Parents Opposed to Pot Argues Pitt Study Neglects Increased THC

1
Parents Opposed to Pot, a group opposed to the legalization of marijuana, criticizes a recent University of Pittsburgh study which found no correlation between pot use and mental health. They contest the results and insist that since the long-term study began in 1987, “skunk” or high THC pot has been on the rise.

Harvard’s Madras Critiques University of Pittsburgh Marijuana Study

10
Bertha Madras, professor of psychobiology at Harvard Medical School, has printed a critique listing 20 flaws to a recent study finding no differences in physical or mental health problems between users and non-users of marijuana.

“Post-Katrina Stress Disorder: Climate Change and Mental Health”

1
Writing for Truth-Out, hurricane Katrina survivor G. Maris Jones writes: “To adapt to a changing climate, survivors of these catastrophes - especially those in marginalized, low-income communities - need long-term physical and mental health services.” She adds a concurrent call to “assume our responsibility to make positive change through action on climate change.”

“Belief That Mental Illness Can Be Contagious Contributes To Isolation”

0
Tania Lombrozo for New Hampshire Public Radio (nhpr) asks, “could it be that some people believe psychiatric disorders can be contagious?” A new study in the Journal of Memory & Cognition says “yes,” and adds that this perception influences the way people interact with mental health category members.

Addiction is Not a Disease; It is Learned by the Brain and Can Be...

4
-Salon discusses the ideas of neuroscientist Marc Lewis, a psychologist, former addict, and author of the book, The Biology of Desire: Why Addiction is Not a Disease.

Many Physicians Don’t Understand Key Facts about Prescription Opioid Addictions

11
A Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health survey of 1000 US primary care physicians found that many do not understand basic medical facts about the addictive nature of the opioids they are prescribing.

Researchers Gain Insight into Stimulant Effects on Brain

8
Researchers believe that they have gained a clearer understanding of how cocaine, amphetamines and related psychostimulant drugs "disrupt the normal functioning of the dopamine transporter in the brain."

Does Substance Abuse Lead to Homelessness or Vice Versa?

1
-There seem to be no "causal" relationships between homelessness and substance abuse, argue three Australian researchers.

A Review of Issues Surrounding Marijuana and Madness

5
-What does the balance of evidence say about the relationship between cannabis use and increased risk of psychotic reactions?

Critics Attack Headline-making Marijuana-Psychosis Study

4
-James Coyne and others criticize a UK study for deliberately trying to be politically manipulative.

Brain Drugs and Corporate Climbers

8
-There's rising use of "cognitive enhancement" and energy-increasing psychiatric drugs among stressed workers and ambitious executives.

“My Road to Hell was Paved with Xanax”

8
-Ashley Zlatopolsky writes about how receiving a benzodiazepine for anxiety led to a severe, problematic addiction.

Does Alcoholics Anonymous Work?

1
-The Atlantic investigates the scientific evidence -- and lack thereof -- for Alcoholics Anonymous and other types of addiction treatment.

One-sixth of College Students Misuse ADHD Stimulants

4
About 17% of college students take stimulants such as Ritalin and Adderall, primarily because they believe the drugs will help them improve their academic performance.

Highly Praised Anti-Addiction Program For Prisoners Was “Fraud”

2
-A psychiatric study widely hailed in Swedish media which led to new treatment guidelines was a "fraud," states health reporter and researcher Janne Larsson.

Towards a Ban on Psychiatrically Diagnosing and Drugging Children

61
Instead of hope and enthusiasm for their futures, too many children now grow up believing they are inherently defective, and controlled by bad genes and biochemical imbalances. They are shackled by the idea that they have ADHD and then subdued by the drugs that inevitably go along with the diagnosis. Unless something intervenes, many of them will go on to pass their days on Earth in a drug-impaired, demoralized state.

Is Addiction a Brain Disease? — Debating the 12-Step Model

2
-Dr. Lance Dodes and Dr. Joseph Nowinski debate the disease-based model of addiction and the 12-step approach in The Fix.

Why Mental Health Systems Should Be Organized Under Alcohol and Drug Systems

13
While I was in charge of the public systems for both mental health and addictions in Oregon, I found it a challenge to maintain an equal focus on alcohol/drug problems compared to mental health. One big reason for the emphasis on mental health was that the mental health budget was big, about 6 times greater than that for addictions. And that doesn’t even count the hidden funding for psychiatric drugs which probably added another 30 or 40% to mental health —atypical antipsychotics are a lot more expensive than Antabuse.

Most People Who Use Drugs Don’t Become Addicted — And Why That’s Important

5
--The former CEO of the UK's National Treatment Agency describes the social circumstances of people most susceptible to addiction.

Playpen Rats Making Popular Comeback, Defy the Brain-disease Model of Addiction

3
-University of Queensland addictions experts challenge last year's Nature editorial that claimed there is a scientific "consensus" that addiction is a brain disease.

The Substance of Substance Use: Talking About Marijuana, Alcohol, and Other Drugs

4
When I was locked in a psychiatric hospital, I wasn't able to have much of a conversation with my parents about what was going on. Phone calls were tense and filled with silence, and as I stood at the ward payphone I was so confused and frozen in fear that each call just confirmed to them how lost I was. Every day as a patient centered around the various prescriptions I was on, and like so many people suffering in a psychosis, helping me became a wait to "find the right combination of medications."