Is It Time to Abolish Borderline Personality Disorder as a Diagnosis?

A new analysis argues that the BPD label can reinforce stigma, discredit lived experience knowledge, and pathologize neurodivergence, gender diversity, and culturally different forms of emotional expression.

17
17620

Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) is a controversial diagnosis that some psychiatrists have argued “no longer has a place in clinical practice.” The stigma around this label is such that mainstream clinical psychologist Marsha Linehan, leading BPD expert and creator of Dialectical Behavior Therapy (itself the target of criticism from trauma survivors), advises her patients not to disclose their BPD diagnosis in order to avoid mistreatment from healthcare professionals.

A new article published in the International Journal of Mental Health Nursing argues that BPD is not a neutral clinical label, but rather a mechanism of social control that can be used to punish nonconformity, discredit lived experience knowledge, and silence claims of harm caused by diagnosis. The authors, led by Laurence Cobbaert from the University of New South Wales in Australia, contend that what clinicians often interpret as emotional instability, excessive dependence, or interpersonal difficulty as a result of underlying BPD are actually responses to trauma, sensory differences, and structural disadvantage.

The BPD label can revictimize, retraumatize, and undermine patient’s and service user’s credibility. This label can also contribute to coercive treatment, stigma, discrimination, harm, and refusal of care. For these reasons, the authors believe BPD should be abolished as a diagnosis. They write:

“This paper contends that the BPD construct is a source of structural exclusion, health injustice and a producer of distress through epistemic violence. The BPD label functions as a regulatory category of social control, disciplining social nonconformity, trauma, gender and sexual diversity and culturally specific forms of emotional expression and relationality into a narrow hierarchical model of behavioural morality. Based on these problematic ideological foundations, abolishing BPD as a diagnostic category is a necessary precondition for decolonising mental health, and for developing forms of care that are relationally safe and accountable, inclusive, sensory-informed, culturally responsive, equitable and just.”

A Problematic Diagnosis

Women and LGBTQ+ individuals are more likely to receive a BPD diagnosis. According to the DSM-5, 75% of people diagnosed with BPD in a clinical setting are women. A 2021 study found that sexual minority service users and patients were 59% more likely to be diagnosed with BPD when controlling for factors such as age, gender, and PTSD. A similar study from 2024 found that transgender and gender diverse patients were 3 times more likely to be diagnosed with BPD.

Past research has linked BPD diagnosis to stigma and discrimination, including beliefs that BPD is untreatable, negative clinician attitudes, discrimination in crisis care, being denied treatment, being made to feel like a burden, and damage to self-image. People with this diagnosis have described the label as derogatory and pejorative. A 2022 scoping review reported that 58% of people diagnosed with BPD in their study reported increased anxiety due to discrimination associated with the BPD label, with 71% saying healthcare providers did not take them seriously.

Experts have also argued that the BPD label is often used to discredit patient and service user experiences and testimony. One clinician contends that this issue is especially problematic for women, where the BPD label “clusters women who dissent, who disobey, who resist together, as if these reactions were signs of pathology rather than spirit against the odds.”

One lived experience expert argued that BPD diagnosis oppresses abuse survivors by divorcing their behaviors from the abuse they endured, allowing abusers to evade accountability, pathologizing anger and rage, and allowing abusers to reverse the roles of victim and offender. A 2020 meta-analysis found that people with a BPD diagnosis were nearly 14 times more likely to report childhood adversity and abuse compared to the general population, and more than 3 times as likely compared to people with other psychiatric diagnoses.

Through the lens of “epistemic injustice,” which includes diagnostic labels discrediting the people that receive them, BPD diagnosis could be viewed as a tool for silencing women, LGBTQ+ individuals, and abuse survivors.

A Critical Analysis of BPD

The goal of the current work was to critically examine BPD diagnosis and how it reflects westernized, patriarchal, ableist, sexist, and heteronormative assumptions rather than a universally applicable understanding of an underlying “disease.” The authors also wanted to identify harms related to BPD diagnosis.

Informed by decolonial and feminist scholarship, as well as lived experience, the authors performed a critical discourse analysis around BPD. This method involves examining how people in power use language to shape narratives and exert control over other groups. The authors drew on psychiatric and clinical literature, mental health policies and historic diagnostic texts, research around gender, colonialism, and neurodiversity, first-person accounts, and lived-experience research. They also disclose that they have lived-experience of poor mental health and being harmed by psychiatric treatment which shapes their “ethical refusal of diagnostic neutrality toward BPD.”

The authors begin their analysis by addressing the claim that long-term therapy can lead to “dependence” for people with a BPD diagnosis. They argue that “dependence,” rather than being treated as part of a shared human condition, is pathologized and devalued. This is similar to the way psychiatry framed “hysteria” in the past as a way of pathologizing women’s emotional expression. People marked as “dependent,” often women, are viewed as attention-seeking, manipulative, and clingy. Through this view, expressing needs is reframed as weakness, instability, or moral failure in need of correction, often through coercion. Essentially, people in positions of power decide what constitutes appropriate expressions of need, and justify dismissive attitudes and coercive practices meant to correct anything that falls outside that “appropriate expression.”

The authors argue that BPD language marginalizes people with unique ways of processing sensory information. For example, psychiatry frames suicidality and non-suicidal self injury as an expression of poor attachment to others or problems regulating emotions. This reflects Western, psychiatric assumptions that are not universal. Emerging research has identified sensory processing differences, such as those seen in autism, as strong predictors of suicidality and self injury. The focus on pathological attachment and poor emotional regulation invalidates the experience of overwhelming sensory distress.

According to the authors, people with autism are often incorrectly labeled as having BPD. These patients and service users report having their experiences of overwhelming sensory distress, that can lead to suicidality and self-harm, reframed in BPD language such as “attention seeking,” “manipulative,” and “exaggeration.” Similarly, in therapy such service users have had their sensory issues dismissed as just a manifestation of emotional or relational instability. This is an example of people in positions of power deciding what types of distress are meaningful, and interpreting any departure from that as an inability of patients and service users to understand their own experience.

Attachment theory is often used as a near universal explanation for relationship difficulties common in people with a BPD diagnosis. This theory was largely developed based on research with White, middle-class, Western families and positions the kinds of parenting, caregiving, independence, and emotional expression valued by those groups as the “correct” way to do attachment. However, non-White, non-Western, and collectivist communities can have different values around attachment and emotional expression.

Applying attachment theory to these groups risks labeling culturally different relationships as dysfunctional, and has historically been used to pathologize indigenous families as fragmented, inconsistent, and emotionally neglectful, resulting in forced, often violent removal of indigenous children from their families. This is an example of people in positions of power deciding what kinds of relationships and attachments are healthy, and framing anything else as pathological.

The authors note that while people with a BPD diagnosis often have their experiences scrutinized by mental health professionals, the discipline largely refuses to apply that same scrutiny to its own practices. They point to ECT and antidepressants as dubious treatments with documented harm, overstated effectiveness, and compromised informed consent. This erodes trust in mental health systems and may lead patients and service users to disengage from care. However, when people with a BPD label question treatments that they find unhelpful or harmful, this is framed as proof of their underlying “illness.”

The authors argue that BPD diagnostic criteria is strongly influenced by assumptions about gender, sexuality, and acceptable forms of identity and self expression. Sexual and gender minorities are more likely to endorse BPD diagnostic criteria. However, the authors believe that the stress caused by discrimination, being a minority, and identity conflict are often misunderstood by clinicians as symptoms of a personality disorder rather than as reactions to systemic oppression.

They point to psychiatry’s history of pathologizing LGBTQ+ individuals as a way to police nonconformity. This includes classifying homosexuality as a “sociopathic personality disturbance” in the DSM-I, and “gender identity disorder” in the DSM-IV being framed as a failure to achieve a “stable identity.” This is an example of people in positions of power deciding what identities are healthy, and pathologizing other ways of being.

BPD diagnosis often contributes to the suffering it is meant to explain and address. This label can intensify shame, damage self-worth, undermine credibility, and result in patients and service users being denied care. It can also create a self-reinforcing cycle of harm and invalidation. For example, a patient or service user objects to a treatment as unhelpful or harmful, but rather than considering that objection as a reasonable response to feeling unsafe, harmed, or invalidated, clinicians tend to interpret it as further evidence of the BPD diagnosis.

The authors believe the BPD diagnosis should be abolished in favor of approaches that are capable of addressing distress without relying on a harmful label. This would include treatment approaches that prioritize relational safety, cultural responsiveness, sensory-informed care, epistemic justice, professional accountability, and lived experience leadership. They conclude:

“Abolishing the BPD construct is not an act of recklessness, but an act of clinical, ethical and epistemic responsibility. It opens the possibility for care rooted in self-determination rather than compliance, compassion rather than suspicion and justice rather than containment. Until psychiatry is willing to relinquish the diagnostic power to name certain personalities, identities, or forms of self-expression as disordered, any conversation about “destigmatising” BPD and improving treatment outcomes will remain fundamentally misdirected.”

****

Cobbaert, L., Maloney, E., Harding, K., & James, S. (2026). Dismantling the diagnostic construct of borderline personality disorder: A critical discourse analysis. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 35(2). (Link)

Previous articleRemembering That Day (Revised) by TJ Hamilton
Next articleADHD, a Unicorn in the Psychiatric (Be)wilderness
Richard Sears
Richard Sears teaches psychology at West Georgia Technical College and works as a counseling psychologist in private practice, specializing in person-centered therapy. Earlier in his career, Richard worked in a psychiatric crisis stabilization unit, an experience that exposed him to the harsh realities of a broken mental healthcare system. This fueled his commitment to providing compassionate, person-centered care and advocating for meaningful change in how mental health services are delivered.

17 COMMENTS

  1. in regards to; “that BPD is not a neutral clinical label, but rather a mechanism of social control that can be used to punish nonconformity”

    Aren’t all mental illness labels, by definition, tools of social control because they’re tied to clinical services and an insurance apparatus which seeks to minimize deviance because of fiscal reasons?

    In regards to; “The BPD label can revictimize, retraumatize, and undermine patient’s and service user’s credibility”

    I’ve seen, in person, similar issues with the ADHD label, notably where it is used as a way to drug unruly kids.

    In regards to; “abolishing BPD as a diagnostic category is a necessary precondition for decolonising mental health, and for developing forms of care that are relationally safe and accountable, inclusive, sensory-informed, culturally responsive, equitable and just”

    Honestly, this definitely doesn’t read like a psychiatric or even a medical paper but one churned out by some sociological department which, frankly, I don’t think holds much or any authority. I don’t go into the issues that such departments are often just hotbeds of whatever ideological garbage its donors want to push.

    In regards to; “The authors argue that BPD language marginalizes people with unique ways of processing sensory information”

    Again, doesn’t any “mental disorder” language marginalize people by framing it as necessarily abnormal and outside of normal human functioning?

    in regards to; “These patients and service users report having their experiences of overwhelming sensory distress, that can lead to suicidality and self-harm, reframed in BPD language such as “attention seeking,” “manipulative,” and “exaggeration.”

    1. Autism, by definition, is not characterized by sensory distress or sensory processing disorders. Mistaking a diagnostic addendum for its essence renders the argument invalid.

    2. If BPD just was autism, this would beg the question why people already diagnosed with autism aren’t routinely assigned a BPD diagnosis as well. Clearly, the two labels must describe two different things. It’s also a known issue that “BPD patients” have excessively poor insight into their issues even compared to other people, e.g. such people will not understand why threatening to commit suicide might pose a problem to their families or colleagues because if they did, they wouldn’t do it.

    3. Autism isn’t a diagnosis that conveys any genuine form of “acceptance” regardless of how often generic treatment plans, brought to you by whatever franchise happened to buy its way into your state’s insurance plan (or similarly), are marketized as acts of tolerance, acceptance etc. The autism industrial complex has been usurping civil rights language for the last decade or so with tons of users and or bots propagating these notions nowadays on the internet. It suffices to point out the avalance of 30 or 40-something year old women claiming that getting diagnosed with autism (or ADHD) was somehow life-changing despite the clinical label being practically useless in real-life settings. That ain’t organic growth.

    Report comment

    • How do we determine what is a “valid form of psychiatric nosology?” The fact that we can create a description of certain behavior and find that some people fit that description is hardly proof of validity.

      The head of NIMH (Tom Insel) once stated that the DSM “diagnoses” lacked validity, and were similar to “diagnosing” people based on the quality of chest pain. Another previous NIMH head (Stephen Hyman) criticized the DSM on similar grounds. Are they raging antipsychiatry radicals in your mind? Or do two of the leading psychiatrists who headed up research on psychiatric conditions in the USA perhaps have the right to challenge your claims?

      Report comment

  2. Criticism of the demeaning and predominantly misogynistic BPD label is justified and long overdue. But shouldn’t the arguments brought against it apply equally to the hundreds of other DSM diagnostic categories, which are also subjective culture-bound constructs defined as forms of “psychopathology” resulting from a brain dysfunction, genetic abnormality, or hormonal imbalance?

    Report comment

  3. My life has been ruined by extreme abuse of all sorts since infancy from two of my sisters who were diagnosed, as adults, with personality disorders, including BPD, but had behavioural problems as small children. I have spent most of my life in the psychiatric system due to this abuse. I am 70, one of these sisters has since died, she got on with life until then. I could not get on with mine. The other sister is still in my life and the abuse continues. Many people living with things like depressive disorders grew up with people diagnosed with PDs and suffered terribly. How are we to understand harmful behaviour by people who apparently have no control over their behaviour? The trauma my sisters suffered in the wider family was also suffered by me but on top of that I endured their devastating response in silence. Some who have known my sisters have used to word evil to describe them, I have not done this but I remain at a loss as how to understand people who create such chaos in the lives of others. I also live with the fact that the voices of those who have been harmed by people who have been diagnosed with PDs are never heard.

    Report comment

    • Imagine if people were helped in real time with ongoing reliable functional supports instead of putting efforts, resources, energies and funds into making a diagnostic label stick. ?

      Those doing the labelling have nothing to lose and lots to gain.

      Those diagnosed, labelled and usually drugged may well end up doing “evil” things.

      All this is known and mostly preventable.

      Report comment

      • Yes, proper support is what is needed rather than people being labelled and drugged. The people in my family who were given these labels were doing harmful things long before they were labelled and drugged. I am aware that a label of BPD can stigmatise people and can interfere with them getting help, even for physical health problems. I support a social model of mental distress and have campaigned for decades for child abuse to be identified at the time it is happening and, hopefully, stopped or even prevented altogether. For me, of course, it is too late. One of my sisters was drugged as an adult, the other was not but received psychological support as a child 60 years ago, which was short term and did nothing. In fact it was me who was drugged when I was just 12 years old to enable me to cope with the sibling abuse. Neither drugs nor psychological support made any difference to my sisters. Families can be very good at concealing problems. I don’t know the answers. In the case of my sisters, neither of them saw their behaviour to be the problem even though it was very extreme. It is often people who have been at the receiving end of harmful behaviour are the ones most heavily drugged in an attempt to enable them to cope. Sibling abuse is not well understood and can be devastating.

        Report comment

  4. Thanks for this one, Richard Sears.

    This sentence seems to hold weight in broader contexts: “Essentially, people in positions of power decide what constitutes appropriate expressions of need, and justify dismissive attitudes and coercive practices meant to correct anything that falls outside that ‘appropriate expression.’”

    We live under the control of coercive systems. Our political, economic, social, and religious institutions and their operations are essentially coercive.

    Psychiatry often plays hand maiden to these coercive systems of control, assuming the correctness of these governing systems and structures by which some have such power over the lives of others in the first place.

    Report comment

    • Psychiatry and psychiatric labels are often weaponized for family, relative’s gains. They are also used in high-conflict custody war games, which often have more to do with assets, property, money, than the paramount well-being of the child/ren.

      Essentially one parent is diagnostically labelled and made to be unfit, or the parent is incompetent because the child, children are diagnostically labelled due to poor parenting.
      Admittedly the criteria is rigorous, but still these psychiatric invasions occur.

      Report comment

  5. By the third time I was placed in a nationally known DBT-based residential care program to treat my “BPD”, I was told that I was not able to be helped, and released to fend for myself. I now realized how trapped that diagnosis kept me, with over 40 inpatient stays in 6 years because I “wanted” to “commit suicide”. That was NOT what I WANTED to do; I felt I had no choice. Because no one was giving me any other options. Even the mental health professionals painted a grim picture of my incurable future and was told that I had no hope.

    It has been three and a half years since my last hospitalization and what has helped the most was getting kicked out of that stupid mental hospital and given the opportunity to break free from the diagnosis that trapped me for so many years. They didn’t realize they were doing me the biggest favor. I feel like I’ve build a tool belt of skills (thank you Marsha!) and have been told by my therapist that I could run my own program if I wanted to with the knowledge of DBT I have. DBT is NOT the problem, “BPD” is. I believe my diagnosis of BPD has prevented me from other diagnoses that explain the beautifully intricate, unique, and sensitive person that I am.

    Report comment

  6. This!!! I was diagnosed with BPD while locked up in Provo Canyon School, a troubled teen institution notorious for abuse. I was told that I had a permanent mental illness and my perceptions weren’t real. That I had to take massive amounts of Lithium for the rest of my life to protect everyone from my condition. I was not let out of there until I signed a document that said I agreed with all of it. My abusive parents have held on to that diagnosis, because it gives them a very tidy way to negate any harms by them I complain about. It has been with me for 35 years. It needs to be taken away. It is too easy to label and the label is serious. I actually have CPTSD, and treating my trauma actually helps but it took so long to get there.

    Report comment

  7. We need more articles like this. Many thing in the psychiatric sphere are simply outdated, unscientific and need to be addressed. The issue with us human beings is that our minds operate by making grossly oversimplified models of the world in order to interpret and understand it. And that is exactly what happens in science as well. We need to try our hardest to understand all of the many nuances and variations of the human condition; that is something we sure aren’t trying to do hard enough.

    Report comment

  8. There has been a campaign for years (which has gone more quiet) in the UK to change the name of this kind of presentation to more accurately encompass the struggles. There is a huge amount of stigma attached to BPD that is for sure, and what saddens me most is often what’s led to this presentation is not explored or given enough weight and the person suffering is blamed for their difficulties (the stigma). I don’t think anyone would choose the feelings and ups and downs that people who get this label deal with. There are many people however who struggle with these kind of patterns and really need help understanding what is going on for them so that they can work on what is in their control, and who are not always encompassed better (but sometimes also are e.g neurodivergence or PTSD) in other diagnostic categories (I agree many of them flawed). If BPD is explained without the stigma and too much emphasis on the name/label this can sometimes be helpful, as many people with this presentation do feel lost around why they lose friends, what is happening with them emotionally etc.

    Report comment

  9. Marsha Linehan has made a successful professional career from promoting BPD and its various presentations. DBT programs, books, courses, talks, and more.

    BPD has to be one of the most ruinous labels a person could ever have. REFUSE THIS LABEL. Seek an alternative explanation for behaviours.

    Even when psych notes don’t label, the psychiatrist (psychologist, referring doctor) can apply a label, change a label at any time along the way.

    Get the help required without the label. Ask the practitioner what label they are going to submit to the relevant government agency, insurance company, and ask them why that label has been chosen. Probably because it guarantees the healthiest financial returns to the practitioner.

    The practitioner needs the label for their own financial purposes. The label justifies the service that they provide.

    Report comment

    • Exactly, Vic.
      That’s the foundation of the entire mental health racket: without a DSM label, there can be no insurance coverage for the psychiatrist’s “service,” no matter how harmful or useless it may turn out to be.
      Where is the financial and moral accountability?

      Report comment

LEAVE A REPLY