Sexual Violence in Psychiatric Hospitals Is Enabled by Institutional Failures, New Review Finds

A systematic review reveals how permissive ward cultures, inadequate safeguarding, and gendered power imbalances leave psychiatric inpatients vulnerable to sexual assault and feeling responsible for their own safety

0
17

News reports from around the world have documented sexual assaults by staff and other patients in inpatient psychiatric wards. In the UK, sexual assault of patients in psychiatric facilities has been called a “national scandal” and “commonplace,” while experts in the US have referred to these cases as a “systemic problem.” A new systematic review published in BJPsych Bulletin finds that sexual violence in psychiatric hospitals is not simply the result of perpetrators’ behavior. According to the authors, led by Yue Deng from King’s College London, institutional cultures of permissiveness and dismissal around sexual assault, as well as inadequate safeguarding, significantly contribute to sexual violence in inpatient facilities. The authors write:

“Participants’ accounts suggest that sexual violence was often minimised – by patients themselves but also by staff. Some patients seemed to downplay non-physical harassment as a means of coping with a hostile environment, whereas others reported that staff had dismissed their concerns. This pattern echoes the concept of institutional betrayal, where trusted institutions fail to protect or validate individuals, thereby compounding harm … Participants described adopting their own safety strategies – locking doors, avoiding certain peers or confronting inappropriate behaviour. Although these actions reflect the boundary-setting and heightened vigilance described in trauma theory, they also signal a transfer of responsibility for safety from the institution to the individual. Such reliance on patient-led resistance risks exacerbating emotional strain, as indicated by accounts of chronic fear, hypervigilance, dissociation and withdrawal.”

Sexual Assault in Inpatient Psychiatric Wards is Common, Traumatic, and Often Not Reported

A 2013 report found that women admitted to psychiatric wards in Victoria, Australia experienced high levels of sexual assaults, with 45% saying they had experienced sexual assault during inpatient admission and 85% saying they felt unsafe while hospitalized. When patients reported sexual assault, 82% said the nurses were “not at all helpful.” Research from the US found similar numbers, with up to 45% of patients reporting sexual violence during inpatient admission. Reports from both the UK and US have identified staffing shortages and other systemic issues as contributing to the high sexual assault rates in inpatient psychiatric settings.

A 2018 investigative report from The Age found that sexual assaults were often not reported to police or patients’ families, with families being told in only 25% of cases and police reports filed in just 40%. A 2021 ProPublica investigation found that staff at a Chicago psychiatric hospital did not report the possible sexual assault of a patient until journalists began asking questions. An investigation by SkyNews and The Independent found that just 11% of sexual assault allegations in NHS mental health trusts were referred to the police. In 2023, The Guardian reported that psychiatric patients making sexual assault allegations are often not believed, with one patient detailing how staff accused her of lying and took no action after she reported an assault.

Past research has linked sexual assault to a number of poor psychological outcomes including increased risk of PTSD, depression, suicide, anxiety, emotional distress, alcohol dependence, sleep disturbances, antisocial and borderline personality disorders, schizophrenia, and psychosis.

Study Details

This study aimed to collect and examine research around patients’ experiences of sexual violence in psychiatric inpatient settings. In order to be included in the current research, studies had to be peer-reviewed, qualitative investigations of first-hand accounts related to experienced or witnessed sexual assaults during inpatient admission, or perceived sexual safety within inpatient wards. In total, the authors examined data from six studies including 78 participants. Most included studies focused on female patients admitted to mixed-gender psychiatric wards. The authors analyzed interview data from all included studies for recurring themes.

Most participants in the included studies were women (63 of 78, 80.8%). Participants reported numerous experiences of sexual violence and assault, including sexual harassment, sexualized comments, intimidation, coercion, exploitation, and sexualized physical violence. The authors identified three overarching themes in the data.

(1) “A culture of permissiveness and dismissal” dealt with how sexual violence is normalized in inpatient psychiatric settings through both patients downplaying the seriousness of their experiences and an institutional culture that often ignores patients’ concerns. The authors believe that patients sometimes downplayed sexual harassment and other inappropriate behaviors as a way of coping with the unsafe ward environment. Staff frequently dismissed reports of sexual violence and harassment or treated incidents as insignificant. Patients reported that staff often ignored or delayed responding to concerns around sexual safety. There were also some reports of staff sexually harassing patients and crossing personal boundaries. Overall, patients felt that staff did not take their concerns seriously.

(2) “Everyday fear, hypervigilance and resistance” dealt with patients’ persistent fear of experiencing sexual violence and their sense that it was up to them to prevent it. Patients reported heightened anxiety and vigilance due to the threat of sexual violence. Some patients developed strategies to defend against sexual assault, including locking bedroom doors and avoiding other patients. Those that were sexually assaulted reported fear, disgust, increased psychological distress, hypervigilance (as often seen in PTSD), dissociation, immobility, and emotional withdrawal. The authors note that patients often felt responsible for their own safety. This means the institutions were likely not providing adequate safety and protection. The increased distress and hypervigilance related to the fear and/or experience of sexual violence also undermined recovery.

(3) “Gendered power dynamics in open and mixed-gender spaces” dealt with how the physical layout of inpatient wards and power imbalances contributed to patients’ vulnerability. Mixed-gender wards and insufficiently separated sleeping areas increased the likelihood of unwanted sexual encounters. For example, some female participants reported male patients entering their bedrooms at night. A lack of staff supervision made some patients feel unsafe in certain areas of the wards. Some female patients that were involuntarily detained reported feeling powerless because they were unable to leave the ward or remove themselves from unsafe situations.

The authors argue that improving patient safety around sexual violence cannot be accomplished by simply responding to individual incidents. Instead, they believe it would require significant changes to the organization and culture of psychiatric services.

Trauma-informed care can ensure that staff and patients recognize the potential impact of sexual violence. This would also include treating patients that report sexual violence sensitively and without judgment. Psychiatric hospitals should provide gender-specific spaces, especially for sleeping and personal areas. Inpatient facilities need consistent procedures for identifying, reporting, and responding to sexual violence. Staff should receive training around how to appropriately handle reports of sexual assault and maintaining professional boundaries. These facilities must also create an environment where reporting sexual assault does not result in dismissal or negative consequences and ensure that patient safety is the responsibility of the healthcare institutions rather than the individual patients. The authors conclude:

“Sexual violence in psychiatric in-patient care is enabled by ward cultures that normalise harm, weak safeguarding and gendered power imbalances. Urgent action is needed to implement trauma-informed, gender-sensitive practices and secure spatial boundaries and consistent incident responses, alongside policies that enable safe disclosure and accountability.”

This research had several limitations. Only a small number of studies and participants were included in the current work. The sample had limited representation of men and no representation of non-binary or transgender individuals. The included studies all came from Western, English-speaking countries. The small, non-representative sample as well as the lack of included studies from outside the Western world significantly limits the generalizability of the findings. Sexual violence was not the primary focus of most of the included studies. This means that some experiences were likely not explored with sufficient depth.

****

Deng, Yue, Butler, J., & Oram, S. (2026). Patients’ experiences of sexual violence in psychiatric in-patient care: Systematic review and synthesis of qualitative studies. BJPsych Bulletin, 1–8. (Link)

Previous articleWritten In Scars by Jack Savoretti
Richard Sears
Richard Sears teaches psychology at West Georgia Technical College and works as a counseling psychologist in private practice, specializing in person-centered therapy. Earlier in his career, Richard worked in a psychiatric crisis stabilization unit, an experience that exposed him to the harsh realities of a broken mental healthcare system. This fueled his commitment to providing compassionate, person-centered care and advocating for meaningful change in how mental health services are delivered.

LEAVE A REPLY