Zombies Must Be Dualists


In this piece forĀ Nautilus, Sean Carroll introduces the idea of a “philosophical zombie,” beings that look and behave exactly like humans, but lack the internal mental experience of humans. He reflects on what the possible existence of such “zombies” would mean about consciousness and our philosophy of mind.

“The big question about zombies is a simple one: Can they possibly exist? If they can, itā€™s a knockout argument against the idea that consciousness can be explained in completely physical terms. If you can have two identical collections of atoms, both of which take the form of a human being, but one has consciousness and the other does not, then consciousness cannot be purely physical. There must be something else going on, not necessarily a disembodied spirit, but at least a mental aspect in addition to the physical configuration.

When we talk about whether zombies are possible, we donā€™t necessarily meanĀ physicallyĀ possible. We donā€™t need to imagine that we could find an honestā€toā€goodness zombie here in our real world, made out of the same particles that you and I are made from (if youā€™re not a zombie, which Iā€™m going to assume henceforth). Weā€™re just imagining a possible world, with a different fundamental ontology, even though it might have very similarā€seeming particles and forces. What it would be lacking is mental properties.

As long as zombies are conceivable or logically possible, Chalmers argues, then we know that consciousness is not purely physical, regardless of whether zombies could exist in our world. Because then we would know that consciousness canā€™t simply be attributed to what matter is doing: The same behavior of matter could happen with or without conscious experience.”

Support MIA

MIA relies on the support of its readers to exist. Please consider a donation to help us provide news, essays, podcasts and continuing education courses that explore alternatives to the current paradigm of psychiatric care. Your tax-deductible donation will help build aĀ community devoted to creating such change.

Select Payment Method
Personal Info

Credit Card Info
This is a secure SSL encrypted payment.

Billing Details

Donation Total: $20 One Time