Some Herbal Supplements May Contain Dangerous Pharmaceuticals

Peter Simons
4
1603

Authors from the California Department of Public Health just published an article revealing that hundreds of dietary supplements have been contaminated with pharmaceutical ingredients. Between 2007 and 2016, the FDA identified 776 products containing active, unapproved pharmaceutical chemicals.

“These products were commonly marketed for sexual enhancement, weight loss, or muscle building,” the authors write. “The most common adulterants were sildenafil for sexual enhancement supplements, sibutramine for weight loss supplements, and synthetic steroids or steroid-like ingredients for muscle building supplements.”

Photo Credit: Pixabay

Dietary supplements are a booming industry: reportedly, over 50% of US adults take supplements, and the industry brings in billions of dollars of revenue a year. Unfortunately, supplements are not tested by the FDA before being put on the market. Legally, they are considered “food,” so they do not fall under the stricter regulations for pharmaceutical drugs, which must demonstrate studies of efficacy and side effects before marketing to the public. Supplements may market to the public without any such testing, although the FDA tests them after sale, just as it does for foodstuffs.

Presumably, most people taking dietary supplements are taking them as an alternative to pharmaceuticals, believing that they are an “all-natural” remedy. However, without their knowledge, they may be ingesting dangerous drugs—in some cases, drugs that have been recalled due to serious side effects.

For instance, people who are under the impression they are building muscle with natural ingredients may be ingesting synthetic steroids, known to cause heart attacks, kidney damage, and liver damage, in addition to acne and hormonal changes.

Likewise, people taking herbal remedies for weight loss may be ingesting sibutramine—which, under the brand name Meridia, was taken off the EU and US markets in 2010 due to its known risks of stroke and heart attack (Meridia was also found to be barely more effective than placebo for weight-loss). The selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) fluoxetine (marketed as the antidepressant Prozac) was also detected in weight-loss supplements, and the authors note that this could lead to suicidal thinking, abnormal bleeding, and seizures.

In addition, men who believe they are taking an herbal remedy for erectile dysfunction may actually be ingesting sildenafil (brand name Viagra), which is a vasodilator known to cause heart attacks, stroke, vision loss, and hearing loss. Additionally, an unapproved SSRI called dapoxetine was also detected in these types of supplements.

According to the authors, other supplements “were marketed to assist with various conditions including joint pain, muscle pain, osteoporosis, bone cancer, sleep issues, gout, and prostate health.” These types of supplements contained a variety of pharmaceuticals, but most commonly included diclofenac, which is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug, and dexamethasone, an anti-inflammatory steroid.

The current study found that, between 2007 and 2016, the FDA identified 146 different companies selling herbal supplements with active pharmaceutical ingredients, so this is not just an isolated incident with a few companies responsible. Instead, this appears to be a widespread problem—and the researchers found that it is actually becoming worse: more products were identified in recent years. In addition, many of the companies were warned repeatedly by the FDA for these violations—after which they sometimes changed the ingredients to a different unapproved pharmaceutical.

“These products continue to be sold and are potentially dangerous even after FDA warnings,” the authors write.

The researchers also found that 157 of the supplements contained more than one pharmaceutical ingredient, and some contained up to 6 different pharmaceuticals. As these ingredients may interact with one another, this is a particularly dangerous problem.

But just how dangerous is the addition of small amounts of pharmaceutical ingredients?

According to the researchers from the California Department of Public Health, “Dietary supplement use was associated with 23,000 emergency department visits and 2,000 hospitalizations in the United States each year. Serious adverse events reported with the use of dietary supplements include stroke, acute liver injury, kidney failure, pulmonary embolisms, and death.”

In an invited commentary in JAMA Network Open, Pieter A. Cohen, MD, writes that this problem is “dereliction of duty” on the part of the FDA. Official warning letters were sent to only seven of the 156 companies. Less than half of the supplements identified by the FDA were actually subject to a recall, and even this was considered a “voluntary recall”—meaning the FDA did not make it mandatory. The majority of the supplements remain for sale with no clear marker identifying them as potentially dangerous.

Cohen’s research team has separately identified two “experimental stimulants” in weight-loss supplements, and he writes that although they informed the FDA, that organization has yet to issue warnings or even notify the public.

Cohen urges that the FDA more aggressively use its warnings and public advisories to inform the public and regulate offending companies. He also suggests that Congress could reform the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 so that companies would be required to register their ingredients with the FDA before selling supplements to consumers.

 

****

Tucker, J., Fischer, T., Upjohn, L., Mazzera, D., & Kumar, M. (2018). Unapproved pharmaceutical ingredients included in dietary supplements associated with US Food and Drug Administration warnings. JAMA Network Open, 1(6), e183337. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2018.3337 (Link)

 Cohen, P. A. (2018). The FDA and adulterated supplements—Dereliction of duty. JAMA Network Open, 1(6), e183329. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2018.3329 (Link)

Previous articleHow Nurturing Self-Care and Community Creates Better Parents
Next articleThe Crisis in Cochrane: Evidence Debased Medicine
Peter Simons
MIA-UMB News Team: Peter Simons comes from a background in the humanities where he studied English, philosophy, and art. Now working on his PhD in Counseling Psychology, his recent research has focused on conflicts of interest in the psychopharmaceutical research literature, the use of antipsychotic medications in the treatment of depression, and the general philosophical and sociopolitical implications of psychiatric taxonomy in diagnosis and treatment.

4 COMMENTS

  1. Nobody preys on the stupid quite like the supplement industry.

    One of their products that is absolutely atrocious is that garbage they market as “pre workout” The tingling feeling (similar to pins and needles) you may experience when having a pre workout supplement is often the effects of beta-alanine at work. This tingling feeling is know as acute paresthesia. The feeling is most likely caused because of the effect beta-alanine has on your central nervous system.

    I watch the 20 somethings consume this crap and then they watch me twice their age thin body type pile on the same weights they do. WTF need a stimulant “pre workout” have some black coffee, when you are done eat some REAL FOOD. All that protien powder is is food dryied out then you put water in it. Its stupid. Their are some epic rants on Youtube from top bodybuilders about that one.

    The mother of all supplement scams has to be Prevagen, the Bullshit Memory Drug. Don’t let your parents and grand parents buy this !!!

    https://www.google.com/search?q=prevagen+lawsuit

  2. So, let me get this straight, – these “supplements” are considered “foods” by the FDA, but the FDA doesn’t regulate them? That kind of Federal Bureaucratic thinking is how the DEA has given us the heroin & opioid crisis, too! But it still sounds like at least the supplements are SAFER than PSYCH DRUGS!….

  3. The article serves as a reminder to stick with supplements which you know to be properly described on the package and which AREN’T puffed as some kind of magic compound for whatever particular ailment you have, or think you have. Of course this means you need to do your homework so you know what they’re good for. It also helps to know your side effects, e.g., knowing that starting large quantities of niacin is likely to induce flushing, wherein your skin turns red and you feel skin heat like an under the skin sunburn, or that you’ll get the trots taking extremely large quantities of vitamin C, unless you have a virus ailment.

  4. I agree with bcharris here. People who do their own research and take control of their health, understanding why they take each supplement (instead of blindly following doctor’s advice) know what they’re getting themselves into. Those of us who have taken our bodies back will stop taking a supplement if it makes us feel sick or worsens our health. We don’t need doctor permission to make our health decisions for us.

    I think this above research and publicity is a move by Pharma to scare people into believing drugs are safer than OTC supplements simply because a doctor prescribes them. This is a move likely pushed by the AMA and other physician interests pushing for more power and authority for physicians, in hopes of bringing back their exclusive prescribing power, strengthening their elite position in society. This kind of hype reminds me of when L-Tryptophan was taken off the market for a while due to one contaminated batch….only because Western Medicine is very threatened by people being able to take supplements and improve their health. They are afraid of losing their power…it is a move of desperation here.