Profound moments of connection between client and therapist may do more than make therapy feel meaningful. A new study suggests they can help drive recovery.
A new UK study, published in Psychotherapy Research, followed more than 1,000 therapy clients in the United Kingdom and found that experiences of “relational depth”—rare but powerful encounters of closeness and mutual presence—predicted later reductions in depression and anxiety.
The study was led by Gina Di Malta of The Open University, along with Joel Vos, Julian Bond, Biljana van Rijn, and Mick Cooper. It is the first large-scale longitudinal analysis to test whether relational depth precedes symptom change. They write:
“Through these moments of deep connection, clients may come to feel that they and their psychotherapists are ‘on the same page’: bonded and working towards similar goals, with shared understandings of the tasks needed to get there.”
The study addresses a broader tension in the field over how to capture the complex, human work of therapy within systems that prioritize standardization and easy measurement. Managed care, research protocols, and medical frameworks often emphasize techniques and symptom counts, leaving little room for elements like relational depth that often resist quantification. Yet the evidence here suggests that these fleeting, hard-to-measure encounters may be central to why therapy helps at all, raising questions about whether current systems are built to recognize, let alone support, what is most healing in the therapeutic process.
You've landed on a MIA journalism article that is funded by MIA supporters. To read the full article, sign up as a MIA Supporter. All active donors get full access to all MIA content, and free passes to all Mad in America events.
Current MIA supporters can log in below.(If you can't afford to support MIA in this way, email us at [email protected] and we will provide you with access to all donor-supported content.)
I’m certainly in favor of a meaningful relationship based on mutual trust, honesty, consideration, and respect (the author’s term “relational depth” strikes me as pretentious jargon), but have yet to be convinced that psychotherapy, with its inherent power imbalance, is the best context in which to find it.
Would a therapist maintain that supposed emotional bond with his or her client if the latter finds it impossible to continue paying the hourly fee? The answer should be self-evident.
Report comment
I appreciate that the “Biocultural anthropology and Integrated Therapeutic Practices” educated, are speaking out against the scientific fraud and lies of the psych industries.
Honestly, I believe the medical anthropologists will be very important researchers in the future … as one who is supposed to be an “architect” or “judge,” according to 40 hours of unbiased psychological career testing.
But according to less than two hours of biased psychological “care,” plus a bunch of anticholinergic toxidrome induced psychiatric iatrogenesis, my entire life is “a credible fictional story.” How absurd, and insane, DSM deluded psych industries.
Report comment
what ‘relational depth’ ? most services offer brief sessions and the entire focus is on an impoverished view of ‘recovery’ based on drug company created tick box questionnaires like the phq9 – there is hopefully a temporary alliance and all therapists should be checking in to ensure the person is comfortable with the therapist and if not let them know they can change therapists if needed. Its all a house of cards, researchers have shown that the research for therapy is very poor quality.
Report comment
Dear people, this is a mental illness. Obviously we have higher rate of treatement resistence. Which is indicating it is multifactorial . Basically we have to do excercise and if you can follow plant based diet. Omega 3 a must, you can take up to 10 gram flax seed oil. Now you make sure you have a good night’s sleep. If your sleep is bad, then your days will be bad. If you are young, then the activities themselves should help your medication work by itself. Depression does not cause any sorrow by itself. It just diminishes your ability to function as a human being. So if you think you can function, then do not take medication. Otherwise, check for TRD and try taking herbs like turmeric, tulsi, and ashwagandha to reduce inflammation. SSRIs do not address inflammation. So it will reduce its functionality as you take more stress. I was able to pass university exams in pharmaceutical science. But I could not work as a chemist in a pharma because of my depression related stress. First thing is, you are wrong when you think depression is your illness. You are not your brain, and you are the one who thinks behind the brain. So the problem is your vehicle has a factory default.
Just discard all your thoughts that belongs to this body and bodily being and become yourself and keep feeding your true self. As you feed yourself like grass when it flourish no weed can enter. No need of a third-party help at all. Divine intervention is true. Karmic account is true then you will never ask god why me? Never ever ask why me, people who think they do not reincarnate think why me. You had such a great life for long time. It is the time to upgrade your soul. Let the worldly people upgrade worldly knowledge
Report comment
Clown parade of fake “experts” who have done nothing to actually learn from the few failings of psychiatry they happen to be aware of, so long as they remain fake “experts”.
Report comment