This week Mad in America examines three new articles around adverse effects of therapy. The first takes a look at how trauma-focused therapy can create or reinforce false memories. The second connects therapy to the spread and maintenance of neoliberal values, shifting focus away from systemic issues towards individual “failures.” The third examines how therapy for eating disorders may cause harm, and how that harm is not appropriately monitored or reported.

Trauma-Focused Therapy and False Memories
A new article published in Memory examines how trauma focused psychotherapy can affect memory, and in some cases may create or reinforce false memories. Authors Susanna Niehaus from the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts in Switzerland and Michaela Sonnicksen from University Bonn in Germany argue that false memories can have significant psychological and social consequences, including reduced well-being.
The authors contend that misconceptions about repressed memories are common and widespread. While some experts have argued that traumatic memories are typically repressed and inaccessible to conscious awareness, the authors note that research does not provide consistent evidence for this claim. In fact, empirical findings indicate that traumatic memories are “well-anchored” and often cause intrusions and flashbacks. Past research suggests that the supposed repression of traumatic memories is better explained by ordinary forgetting, suggestion, organic causes, or malingering.
Despite research findings, many psychiatrists still hold beliefs that traumatic memories are often repressed. The authors point to one study that surveyed 258 psychotherapists in which 82% reported they believed their patients had repressed trauma despite the patient not reporting it and 67% reported that their patients had discovered memories of sexual abuse during therapy. More than one-third also reported using specific techniques to uncover repressed memories during therapy. The authors consider these beliefs particularly concerning due to the influence therapists can exert over their clients.
One of the authors’ central arguments is that even appropriately conducted trauma focused therapy may unintentionally reinforce false memories. Patients may have developed false memories from any number of other sources including previous therapy, suggestive conversations with other people, exposure to trauma-related content on social media, previous attempts to actively recover repressed memories, and online self-assessment tools that encourage rushed, often inaccurate diagnoses in an effort to sell supposed cures.
The authors also point to specific practices on the part of therapists that may induce false memories. Therapists may interpret unexplained psychological symptoms as evidence of early childhood sexual abuse, encourage patients to actively search for repressed memories of traumatic experiences, and/or use suggestive questioning or visualization techniques. This can result in patients gradually developing increasingly detailed memories of events that never occurred or becoming more convinced of an interpretation that was initially uncertain. The authors do not suggest that all trauma focused therapy produces false memories, but rather caution against deliberately attempting to recover supposedly repressed memories in treatment.
Recovered memories can have significant consequences for patients and service users. The authors point to previous work from Michaela Sonnicksen finding that 59% of people who actively worked with a therapist to recover memories of childhood sexual abuse reported temporary deterioration of well-being, with 30% saying the deterioration was permanent. About half of these service users cut contact with family members as a result of treatment.
How Therapy and Self-Help Culture Shifts Blame onto Individuals and Ignores Wider Social Problems
A new article published in the Annual Review of Critical Psychology argues that therapy and self-help culture results in people seeing themselves as a kind of project that requires continuous improvement and management. According to author Milan Urošević from the University of Belgrade in Serbia, this encourages people to take personal responsibility for their own happiness, success, productivity, and psychological well-being, even when wider systemic, social, and economic factors significantly affect their lives and cause distress. This threatens to conceal the true role of systemic and environmental factors in causing distress and larger societal problems, and focuses resources on personal improvement rather than addressing societal issues.
Urošević believes that neoliberal values, such as an emphasis on personal responsibility, competition, personal freedom, and self-reliance, significantly influences how people think about themselves and their responsibilities. This value system encourages individuals to understand themselves as solely responsible for their personal success. As a result, people continually monitor and evaluate their own behaviors, often ignoring social, economic, and systemic factors that affect their successes and failures.
The author contends that the spread of psychological concepts and language into everyday life reinforces these neoliberal values, framing personal difficulties as problems that can only be resolved through individual psychological change. For example, unemployment may be interpreted as a lack of motivation rather than a consequence of a failing economy.
Instead of sources of advice or personal development, the author views self help books as instruments that translate neoliberal expectations into everyday life, regulating thoughts, emotions, and behaviors in accordance with these values. As evidence, Urošević presents the altered focus of self-help literature, which originally dealt with religious and moral values before moving on to business success and personal discipline. This literature now focuses mainly on productivity, habit formation, efficiency, and psychological optimization, all important factors in encouraging individuals to internalize neoliberal values.
The concept of the “self-entrepreneurial fantasy” is the result of therapy and self-help culture underwriting neoliberal values. Under this ideal, people imagine that happiness, success, and authenticity can only be achieved through continuous self-improvement. This morphs personality, emotions, and psychological characteristics into resources that must be managed and optimized. The final result is a population that largely regulates themselves with respect to upholding neoliberal expectations without the need for external supervision and correction. This also functions to shift the blame for systemic failures to individuals, foreclosing criticism of neoliberal values.
Psychotherapy for Eating Disorders May Cause Harm, Highlighting the Need for Greater Accountability
A new article published in the International Journal of Mental Health Nursing argues that psychotherapy for eating disorders can unintentionally cause significant psychological harm. Author Laurence Cobbaert from the University of New South Wales in Australia calls for greater accountability in mental health services, including routine monitoring of adverse effects of therapy and meaningful recognition of lived experience expertise.
According to the author, psychotherapy is not universally helpful for people diagnosed with eating disorders and can result in increased distress, deterioration of eating disorder symptoms, treatment-related trauma, feelings of invalidation, coercion, and loss of autonomy, reduced trust in healthcare professionals, and disengagement from treatment. These adverse experiences, while often reported by people with lived experience expertise, are not appropriately monitored or reported in eating disorder research. For example, a 2023 study found that adverse events in CBT trials for anorexia nervosa were not properly defined or monitored. Of 23 included trials, only one reported on patient dissatisfaction with treatment.
While treatment dropout is often framed as patient non-compliance or lack of motivation, Cobbaert believes it could be evidence of adverse effects. According to past research, 24% of people undergoing CBT for eating disorders dropout of treatment. Similar research found dropout rates between 30% to 50% for both inpatient and outpatient treatment of eating disorders. Reasons for discontinuation of treatment are often not properly documented. While the author does not suggest that all treatment dropout is the result of harm caused by the treatment, he argues that dropout should be treated as a possible indicator of treatment related harm.
Marginalized groups may be at greater risk of eating disorder treatment related harm. Standard treatment approaches may fail to address sensory differences and communication styles for people diagnosed with autism. Generic CBT approaches may be overwhelming when executive function and attention difficulties for people with an ADHD diagnosis are not considered. Transgender and gender diverse patients and service users may not be well served by treatment approaches that overlook gender-related experiences and body-related distress. Indigenous and racial minority patients and service users may suffer when treatment fails to recognize cultural differences.
****
Cobbaert, L. (2026). Iatrogenic harm, psychotherapy, and eating disorders: An urgent call to action. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 35(4). (Link)
Niehaus, S., & Sonnicksen, M. (2026). Trauma therapy: Risks, side effects, and the forensic implications of treatment history. Memory, 1–12. (Link)
Urošević, M. (2026). Governing the Neoliberal Subject Through Therapy Culture – Self-Help Books and “The Self-Entrepreneurial Fantasy.” Annual Review of Critical Psychology, 22. (Link)












