In this interview for Vox, Yale psychologist Paul Bloom provides a critical perspective on empathy and explains why empathy may be harmful in the long run.
“My beef is with empathy in particular, with its role in decision making. Empathy has certain design features that do make it positive in certain restricted circumstances. If you and I are the only people on earth and youâre in pain and I can help you and make your pain go away, and I feel empathy toward you and so I make your life better, empathy has done something good. But the real world is nowhere near as simple. Empathyâs design failings have to do with the fact that it acts like a spotlight. It zooms you in. But spotlights only illuminate where you point them at, and for that reason empathy is biased.
Iâm likely to feel empathy toward you, a handsome white guy, but somebody who is repulsive or frightening I donât feel empathy for. I actually feel a lot less empathy for people who arenât in my culture, who donât share my skin color, who donât share my language. This is a terrible fact of human nature, and it operates at a subconscious level, but we know that it happens. Thereâs dozens, probably hundreds, of laboratory experiments looking at empathy and they find that empathy is as biased as can be.”
