A new study, published in JAMA, investigates the effects of digital media use on ADHD symptoms among adolescents. The results of the twenty-four-month longitudinal study, which excluded youth that presented as ADHD symptom-positive at baseline, indicate a significant increase in ADHD symptoms among adolescents with a higher frequency use of digital media.
“In addition to being distressing for the person affected, having [ADHD] is associated with a number of different health and social outcomes like increased risk of substance use, involvement of the criminal justice system, and educational attainment,” the lead author, Adam M. Leventhal of the University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, writes.
Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), a psychiatric disorder characterized by difficulty sustaining attention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity, is diagnosed in 1 out of 7 children in America, a number three times higher than experts cite as appropriate. Although the CDC recommends a combination of behavioral therapy and medication, this controversial diagnosis is most often treated with methylphenidate hydrochloride (Ritalin), a prescription which may alter the developing brain among children and youth.
“Because nongenetic environmental factors are associated with adolescent ADHD, increasing exposure to environmental risk factors may contribute to increasing ADHD rates in that population,” the researchers write. “A meta-analysis of studies conducted from 1987 to 2011 found that use of traditional forms of digital media (eg, television viewing and video game console playing) was modestly associated with ADHD and related outcomes. Digital media has since evolved.”
Leventhal and colleagues take a precautionary approach in their research, attempting to lower the occurrence of ADHD symptoms in youth by modifying environmental risk factors. If, for instance, specific environmental factors, like digital media use, can be changed, the researchers hope they can prevent the occurrence of these symptoms and lower the rate of diagnosis.
In one of the first attempts to assess the long-term association between ADHD symptom occurrence and high-frequency use of specific modern digital media platforms, the researchers recruited 2,587 high school students from Los Angeles County schools. The research team assessed for ADHD symptoms and frequency of modern digital media use at baseline, 6-month, 12-month, 18-month, and 24-month follow-ups. Students portraying ADHD symptom-positive behaviors at baseline were excluded from the study.
Following 24-months of data collection, 10.4% of the 2,587 youth involved in the study who reported the high-frequency use of digital media – including checking social media, texting, and playing video games on a phone or consul – reported ADHD symptoms, compared to only 4.6% who reported low-frequency use. Results found that males and adolescents with depressive symptoms were more likely to report ADHD symptoms overall.
This study provides support for the influence of nongenetic environmental factors on ADHD symptom development in adolescents, highlighting the need for a comprehensive understating of other factors influencing symptoms of ADHD. These results may provide empowerment for critics of the diagnosis and reinforcement for parents attempting to manage screen time with their children. Jenny Radesky, MD, of the University of Michigan School of Medicine concludes:
“With more timely digital media research, parents may feel more confident in the evidence underlying recommendations for how to manage the onslaught of media in their households.”
Ra, C. K., Cho, J., Stone, M. D., De La Cerda, J., Goldenson, N. I., Moroney, E., … & Leventhal, A. M. (2018). Association of Digital Media Use With Subsequent Symptoms of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder Among Adolescents. JAMA, 320(3), 255-263. (Link)
Any technology which encourages a short attention span will become problematic. We live in a world which is overstimulating. The internet is now designed with the idea that many people will quickly jump from one thing to another in short order. “Smart” phones are making us stupider and decreasing our ability to be mindful and sit with ourselves. This isn’t a good development at all. We are causing people more distress through technology.
But is the use of digital media a cause, or an effect of something else, like the failure to provide the emotional needs of children?
Digital media use is a problem for both kiddos and adults. The people who make this technology know it’s highly addictive. This is comparable to Big Pharma, because they know once someone starts regularly using (the technology, pills), it becomes very difficult to get off of and away from it. It’s capitalism at it’s finest….exploit people to make a profit! What’s scary to me is that most people who use “smart” phones (this is an ironic name) will develop some level of dependency on the technology, meaning they will feel anxious if they don’t have access to it, will crave using it, may develop irritable moods if denied access, and so forth. We are creating a mass of humanity in the developed world of people who have attention spans of gnats.
Do you see yourself as being exploited on here?
I am referencing digital media like social media, gaming, news, and the like. People easily get addicted to their bright screens, and they have a difficult time pulling themselves away because they get some temporary pleasure from the device/activity.
See article on shortened attention spans: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2016/03/12/humans-have-shorter-attention-span-than-goldfish-thanks-to-smart/
But, but, but… I thought “ADHD” was a “genetic brain disorder?” And if it’s not, why are we “treating” it with drugs? How did those 10% of adolescents (and 4+% of the control group!) develop “ADHD” if they didn’t have it at “baseline?” Could it be that “ADHD” isn’t inherited at all?
NO, NO, NO, look the other way people – drugs are god, bow down and worship, never mind about those pesky facts…