A new study published in Health Expectations finds service users often feel a loss of dignity during psychiatric hospitalization. The current work, headed by Amirahmad Shojaei from the Tehran University of Medical Sciences in Iran, reveals four ways service users’ dignity is commonly violated: negative guardianship, dehumanization (including namelessness, and worthlessness), violation of patients’ rights, and depriving patients of their authority. The violation of service user dignity can negatively affect treatment, lessen service users’ desire for recovery, and even reduce their desire to survive. The authors write:
Study Finds Psychiatric Hospitalization Erodes Service User Dignity
Research highlights the loss of dignity that often accompanies psychiatric hospitalization, emphasizing the need for mental health professionals to prioritize patient rights and autonomy.
Hospitalization erodes dignity? What dignity? Dignity implies being able to be who you are without resistance, without apology. It implies the dignity of understanding yourself sufficiently to be at ease with what you are and therefore having no duality, no self-criticism. There is no dignity in needing help from people or institutions who neither love nor understand you. To talk of dignity in this context seems absurd. Perhaps you can talk of the ever whittling down of one’s socially conditioned ‘self-esteem’ which to a large extent determines organismic happiness without having a shred of truth or reality in itself. The self is an illusion – self-esteem is the effect of that illusion on the organism. So we are so far from being able to address these problems actually and intelligently, either as a society or as a critical website like this one. We have to break through into a greater kind of destructive activity, one that will destroy the false consciousness of humanity. Any ideas?
Report comment
“There is no dignity in needing help from people or institutions who neither love nor understand you.”
Now THAT’S the fuckin’ truth.
Why do so many adults allow themselves to have so little sense of their own dignity, of their own ability to meet the demands of living no matter how painful? Why is it so many adults allow their emotional struggles to be seen as pathological?
Psychiatry stomps on the dignity of every human being under the guise of “medical care” when all they’re really doing is dealing drugs or imprisoning innocent people. They began by poisoning the culture with demeaning labels and have since moved on to poisoning people’s brains and bodies and/or locking them up and calling this “treatment”.
There is no dignity in psychiatry.
IMHO.
Report comment
There is no dignity in calling suffering human beings ‘service user’ either, is there. We ruin our children and then the patching of them up we call a ‘service’, and them a user of this service. Destroying our kids and fobbing them off with destructive, brutal, stupid and insane social palliative grifts like psychiatry and psychopharmacology is hardly a service to anyone. It implies that psychiatry and psychopharmacology and psychology are social gifts rather then socio-economic grifts. So there is no dignity afforded to these suffering human beings in anything we say. What I say affords dignity to no-one because there is no-one in what I say. Indeed there IS no-one. The me is the real divided up and chopped into atoms which can then be blamed for all the mistakes of the collective social process which manufactured us all out of the raw material of nature. The fact that nature always was and forever is superior in intelligence and harmony then the social process is proof that the latter is nature’s idiot, nature’s fool.
Report comment
♥️
Report comment
Spot On.
Report comment
Very hard to get this across to people
Report comment
Psychiatry routinely strips people’s dignity “hospitalized” or not. Its systematic dehumanization of the vulnerable acts as a safety valve for those in power because ultimately psychiatry is not about people’s health and wellbeing, it’s about the comfort and satisfaction and feelings of power of its practitioners.
IMHO.
Report comment
Not to mention the financial perks obtained from ties with pharmaceutical companies, from ghost-written articles in professional journals, and other lucrative sources of income….
Report comment
Thank you joel stern! How could I have forgotten all those goodies, aka tools of bribery 🙂
Report comment
Make no mistake. Many psychiatrists are essentially jailers who can if they so choose inappropriately wield power over innocent people’s lives, the mindset underneath all their skillfully manipulative bullshitting being “the cruelty is the point”. All the research in the world can’t change that.
IMHO.
Report comment
?
Report comment
?
Report comment
What about journalism ethics?
Report comment
This is an emergency Mad In America writers, so I recommend you press the big red button and use the emergency weapon, which is your brains. I know it is a tall order because it has been occupied in nothing but data entry and security seeking activities all this time. I know it’s a little rusty and will take time to whirr up again, and many ghosts and moths will be flying around, but let them out through the windows of your eyes.
Oh God, I’m still suffering from the dishonesty of socially conditioned communicative optimism. It’s my insanity, my social conditioning, so let me just be frank. Hallucinogens are your only hope my friends. Otherwise, you may as well call Dignitas and throw your brains in the recycling machine.
Report comment
Forget dignity. Most “mental health workers”, psychiatrists included, are subliminally taught to view people in psychological distress with a certain degree of contempt and most of the time are rewarded for doing so.
IMHO.
Report comment
Face it. The unhealthy desire to infantilize other adults, aka “psychiatry”, feeds the unhealthy desire to control other adults. It’s as simple as that.
Therefore, it’s highly unlikely that people in power, aka “psychiatry”, will ever willingly relinquish the feelings of control that infantilizing other adults inappropriately gives them.
Report comment
In my humble opinion, I would love to read the research that Birdsong and others have done on how mental health workers like myself are “subliminally taught to view people in psychological distress with a certain degree of contempt and most of the time are rewarded for do so.” Please send me the citations. I think I might have missed out on my rewards.
Report comment
In response to your doubts regarding Birdsong’s claim that mental health practitioners feel subliminal (and often unconcealed) contempt for people in psychological distress, this supercilious attitude is abundantly documented in Dr. Jeffrey Masson’s superlative study, “Against Therapy: Psychological Tyranny and the Myth of Emotional Healing.” This so-called profession tends to attract authoritarian personalities who derive no small pleasure–and of course profit–from being able to drug, electroshock, and dictate their subjective opinions on “normality” to those under their care. Please let us know if you can marshal credible evidence of your own to refute Masson’s findings and conclusions.
Report comment
🙂
Report comment
As a recovered patient and staff member I can attest that it is not only the patients but also the staff who lack insight. However only the recovered / recovering patients have insight into what helps them and the staff need to realize this and learn from them.
https://psychrights.org/research/digest/effective/APAMonV31No2.htm
Report comment
That’s not likely to happen with psychiatry calling the shots.
Report comment