Your smartphone may not just be tracking your steps—it could also be assessing your mental health. Depression-tracking apps that analyze your behavior, such as how often you text, where you go, and how long you stay in bed, promise a low-effort way to detect emotional distress. But new research raises a critical question: What happens when technology misunderstands you?
A study led by German researchers argues that these apps often reduce complex emotional experiences to simple data points, reinforcing biases about who “counts” as credible when discussing their mental health. By overlooking the social and cultural contexts that shape distress, mental health apps may not only misinterpret users’ behaviors but also diminish their role as active participants in their own care.
“From an ethical perspective, it is crucial to consider epistemic injustice to promote socially responsible innovations within digital mental healthcare,” the authors write.
This form of injustice, they explain, happens when people are denied the ability to make sense of or share their own experiences. In some cases, users may feel pressured to defer to the app’s assessment rather than their own intuition. In others, the app’s silence during moments of profound internal struggle could lead to isolation and self-doubt.

If I was the real super-psychiatrist of the Universe and someone came in saying they had written an article entitled “Can Your Smartphone Diagnose Depression? The Hidden Risks of Mental Health Apps” for Mad In America, I would say “off to the loony bin with you: don’t hang about: and take MIA with you”, because look how many wrong assumptions are latent and implicit in this comment – the idea that ‘depression’ can be diagnosed by anyone or anything besides the person recognizing that they’re depressed, like there being hidden risks in mental health apps that aren’t merely applications of the structures and assumptions of psychiatry only probably with more caution applied to them not less, and therefore potentially less dangerous in terms of making rash and dangerous prescriptions, such as for an antipsychotic instead of an antidepressant ‘cuz that’ll help you sleep well (which is true, but it helps you sleep well in your bed AND your grave cuz it’s known chronic use is associated with an on average 20 or 25 year shorter life expectancy. Apologies for writing destructive comments but honestly MIA, that’s what’s needed. I always throw the ball into their court though and they rarely respond: what’s wrong with you? I serve the ball and you don’t respond to it. Don’t like Babington? Then let’s have a verbal boxing match instead cuz I wanna give you’re computer brains a headache. To quote the venerable Linton Quesi, my theme will be: “i’m gonna smash their heads in, coz they ain’t got nuffink in em”.
Report comment