Why We Fell for Clean Eating


From The Guardian: Not only is the clean eating movement based on pseudoscientific beliefs not backed up by evidence, but it may also lead to the development of eating disorders. Still, the lifestyle continues to remain popular for a variety of reasons.

“It’s increasingly clear that clean eating, for all its good intentions, can cause real harm, both to truth and to human beings. Over the past 18 months, McGregor says, ‘every single client with an eating disorder who walks into my clinic doors is either following or wants to follow a clean way of eating’.

In her new book, Orthorexia, McGregor observes that while eating disorders long predate the #eatclean trend, ‘food rules’ (such as eating no dairy or avoiding all grains) easily become ‘a guise for restricting food intake’. Moreover, they are not even good rules, based as they are on ‘unsubstantiated, unscientific claims’. Take almond milk, which is widely touted as a superior alternative to cow’s milk. McGregor sees it as little better than ‘expensive water’, containing just 0.1g protein per 100ml, compared with 3.2g per 100ml in cow’s milk. But she often finds it very difficult to convince her clients that restricting themselves to these ‘clean’ foods is in the long run worse for their health than what she calls ‘unrestrained eating’ – balanced and varied meals, but no panic about the odd ice cream or chocolate bar.

Clearly, not everyone who bought a clean-eating book has developed an eating disorder. But a movement whose premise is that normal food is unhealthy has now muddied the waters of ‘healthy eating’ for everyone else, by planting the idea that a good diet is one founded on absolutes.”

Article →­

Support MIA

MIA relies on the support of its readers to exist. Please consider a donation to help us provide news, essays, podcasts and continuing education courses that explore alternatives to the current paradigm of psychiatric care. Your tax-deductible donation will help build a community devoted to creating such change.

Select Payment Method
Personal Info

Credit Card Info
This is a secure SSL encrypted payment.

Billing Details

Donation Total: $20 One Time


  1. Eat your GMO/Round-upTM factory farmed watered with fracking well water food, and shaddup! It’s GOOD for ya!

    Did you know that commercial wheat is sprayed after harvest with Round-up as a desiccant? Yummmmm! Did you know that the wheat commercially grown these days has 4x the number of genes than what our ancestors cultivated? Gluten sensitivity and celiac disease are two different things…

    Look it up.

  2. This is some tortured reasoning. The fact that people with food issues latch onto the “clean food” movement doesn’t mean the movement itself has any causal relationship to eating disorders. Clear case of correlation not meaning causation. Some people use nursing a baby continuously as a means of “purging.” But nursing babies doesn’t cause bulimia. Total logical fallacy.