New Review: Antidepressants Come with Minimal Benefits, Several Risks

A review of research on antidepressant efficacy finds that an unfavorable risk-to-benefit ratio.

10
2691

A recent article published in the Drug and Therapeutics Bulletin examines the state of current research on the efficacy of antidepressant medications.

The authors, Mark Horowitz and Michael Wilcock, state that evidence for clinical antidepressant efficacy is marginally superior to placebo and comes with the potential of mild to severe adverse effects and withdrawal symptoms. They conclude with several suggestions for aiding in successful discontinuation, as well as the recommendation that prescribers be aware of this information and consider giving out fewer antidepressant prescriptions for “shorter periods of time.”

“The Royal College of Psychiatrists has presented recent guidance on how to stop antidepressants in a tolerable way. We believe that increasing awareness about the difficulty that some patients have in stopping antidepressants should lead to more cautious prescribing practice, with antidepressants given to fewer patients and for shorter periods of time. This article discusses the perceived benefits and harms of antidepressant use,” the authors explain.

guy holding pillIn the UK, 1 in 6 adults were prescribed an antidepressant between 2019 and 2020. This common prescribing of antidepressants—particularly SSRIs and SNRIs—persists despite researchers acknowledging that the psychiatric establishment has minimized their downsides. In addition, both US and UK guidelines for treatment have reportedly underestimated both the “severity” and “duration” of antidepressant withdrawal.

Top researchers have acknowledged that support for antidepressant withdrawal is an important need to address within psychiatry. Recent research has found that more than half of people who quit antidepressants experience withdrawal symptoms, and the withdrawal period can last weeks or months, even if tapering is employed.

Based on a review of available research, the current article explores the clinical efficacy of newer generation antidepressant drugs such as SSRIs and SNRIs. British psychiatrists Mark Horowitz and Michael Wilcock also discuss withdrawal and other adverse effects linked to taking antidepressants. They discuss evidence-based methods for aiding individuals who choose to discontinue these drugs.

Much of the research on the clinical efficacy of these antidepressants is based on placebo-controlled trials lasting 6-12 weeks. According to the authors, several meta-analyses of these outcome studies have found a 2-point difference with these drugs compared to placebo, on a scale ranging from 0 to 52—the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAM-D).

The UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) has set 3 points as the clinically significant difference for this scale, although some research considers 3 points too small, suggesting six instead.

Longer studies show even less clinical significance, and studies comparing users of antidepressants with non-users also suffering from depression show no difference in the outcome, although the authors state that more research is needed.

As for the treatment of adolescents, the evidence is also less convincing:

“A recent Cochrane review found no antidepressant had a clinically significant effect compared with placebo, leading the authors to question ‘whether they should be used at all,’ especially considering some antidepressants increased suicide risk compared with placebo in this population.”

Disturbingly, some of the studies reporting significant results for adolescents have been found to exaggerate the benefits of these drugs—from reporting outcomes not listed in the original study protocols to under-reporting risks by “coding suicide attempts in the antidepressant group as ’emotional lability.'”

Despite these findings, the authors report that between 2005 and 2017, antidepressant usage among adolescents has more than doubled.

In terms of long-term adverse effects, a study with patients recruited by primary care physicians found that 64% of patients on an SSRI experienced at least one, while 31% reported three or more. About 20% of patients reported experiencing one of the following effects:

  • Daytime drowsiness
  • Dry mouth
  • Profuse sweating
  • Weight gain

Meanwhile, 25% of patients reported sexual dysfunction, and about 1 in 10 reported “restlessness, muscle spasms or twitching, nausea, constipation, diarrhea or dizziness.”

In a study of individuals self-selected for long-term antidepressant usage, adverse effects were even worse, with:

“71% reporting emotional numbness, 70% reporting feeling ‘foggy or detached,’ 66% reporting sexual difficulties, and 63% reporting drowsiness.”

Research on withdrawal from antidepressants has noted some glaring problems in terms of long-term effects. For example, a systematic review of 24 studies (with 8737 total participants) found that about half of patients who stopped taking SSRIs experienced withdrawal symptoms, regardless of whether they tapered or not.

These withdrawal symptoms can include insomnia, depression, suicidal ideation, and physical symptoms. Some patients reported experiencing withdrawal symptoms months, even years after their discontinuation. In surveys that asked about the severity of these symptoms, 46% of patients said that they were “severe.”

The authors also state that in research on so-called “relapse” from antidepressant discontinuation, this can often be confused with withdrawal symptoms, as recently reported in other studies.

“Withdrawal effects, which include anxiety, insomnia, depression, and appetite changes, all register on depression scales, and so these withdrawal effects in the discontinued group are likely to inflate the apparent relapse rate in this group.”

When discontinuing antidepressants, the authors list several suggestions based on the research literature.

Tapering, although not a guaranteed way to avoid withdrawal symptoms, has been generally found to lead to a “more tolerable” experience than abrupt discontinuation.

The authors advocate for extensive dialogue between healthcare professionals and patients regarding informed consent around potential side effects and withdrawal effects. For example, even though the risk is low, some patients report long-term and event permanent symptoms like “post-SSRI sexual dysfunction.” These and other concerns should be discussed with patients both before being prescribed antidepressants, and when considering discontinuation, the authors believe.

In terms of what may also help, some research suggests that mindfulness-based treatments and cognitive therapy can largely mitigate withdrawal effects. The authors also mention increased psychosocial support, acceptance, peer group support, and individual support as necessary to offer individuals who choose to discontinue.

In addition, extensive tapering, which is not usually done, appears to be helpful. Tapering down over months rather than weeks to very small doses, such as .5% of clinical doses, “allowed the majority (71%) of a group of patients to cease their antidepressant.” Two-thirds of this group had previously experienced difficulty with discontinuation.

Starting with a “test reduction” is also mentioned, where the clinical dose is reduced by 5%, and patients are then monitored for withdrawal symptoms before further tapering.

These strategies would, of course, require the manufacturing of smaller doses of many drugs than are now available, presenting practical difficulties.

The authors conclude:

“There continues to be considerable uncertainty about the benefits of antidepressant use in the short- and long-term, particularly in regard to the lack of a clinically significant difference between antidepressant and placebo treatment. There is increasing recognition of the possibility of severe and long-lasting withdrawal symptoms from antidepressants.
This recognition casts doubt on the relapse prevention properties of antidepressants as these properties have been demonstrated in discontinuation trials in which withdrawal effects may have inflated relapse rates. Antidepressants can have significant adverse effects, which appear to be greater in longer-term use compared with short-term efficacy trials. In light of this uncertain balance of benefits and harms, we should re-visit the widespread—and growing—prescription of antidepressants.”

 

 

****

Horowitz, M., & Wilcock, M. (December 20, 2021). Newer generation antidepressants and withdrawal effects: Reconsidering the role of antidepressants and helping patients to stop. Drug and Therapeutics Bulletin. (Link)

Previous articleTherapy Before Pills Is Great, But Why Wait Till People Are Depressed to Teach Them How to Self-Heal?
Next articleConsumer Regret
Micah Ingle, MA
MIA Research News Team: Micah Ingle is a doctoral student in Psychology: Consciousness and Society at the University of West Georgia. He has published on therapeutic approaches centering the person-in-context, as opposed to the individualizing medical model, and on the characteristics of people high in empathy. His current interests include the intersection of sociopolitical/economic structures and mental health, individualism in psychology, gender, liberation psychology, and mythopoetic perspectives inspired by Jungian thought.

10 COMMENTS

  1. No words from the authors to address the patients who were silenced and mocked for decades when they said and showed how much harm the prescribed drugs were doing to them? The patients who were punished for trying to advocate for themselves with even scarier diagnoses like borderline personality disorder and mocking remarks like, “at some point you’re just going to need a complete personality makeover” and “I don’t know Kate, maybe you just really get to people”? No apology?

  2. ugh. Psychiatrists are bad enough, all by themselves. Add in the work a day “real” (?) doctors who commit acts of psychiatry, usually with no repercussions, and…

    ugh. done. stick a fork in me, done. I -am- thankful that the “antidepressants,” in particular, are being targeted for serious review and debunking. On the one hand, one can argue (as I do) that the various neuroleptics — “atypical,” doesn’t matter — are more damaging. This is true. But…

    the 31 flavors of “antidepressants” are doled out, left and right, to all sorts of people for any and every “problem” imaginable. one problem I have, now? looking back…the family doctors, in particular, know what the “antidepressants” are all about. they’re also the worst offenders on pushing them on vulnerable and/or low status people (read: “weaklings”) and if things don’t pan out…

    refer to some noxious “mental health professional” who gives them kick backs and regular updates on the destruction of the “patient.” ugh.

    also worth noting: the “antidepressants” are often step 1 to the total and complete destruction of individuals and families. 16-20 years old, some flavor “antidepressant.” labels, additional pills, labels, incapacitation…

    5-10 years later, the individual — if alive — may very well be an impoverished psychiatric casualty. thanks, doc. 🙁

  3. The title of this article should read “no benefit—way too many risks to do any good.” Antidepressants, amongst other things, are basically “gateway drugs” to the other psychiatric drugs such as the atypical anti-psychotics and the highly addictive “benzos.” And the other tragic part about these drugs is that M.D.s who are not psychiatrists will prescribe these for all kinds of issues. Sadly, the average person is not aware of how dangerous and evil these drugs really are. Thank you.

  4. Antidepressants are the devil,

    i took 7 months paroxetin for workstress i got some side effects, so i tapered down in 30 days 10mg 9.8mg 9.6mg and so on. After 2 months i get severe side effects couldn’t sleep, panic (never had before) So i reinstated 5mg and then 10mg and my CNS went haywire.

    I’m now 13 months off drugs and severe disabled
    – Everyday in horrific pain all over (nerve dull)
    – Toxic feeling in every fiber of my body
    – Feeling like there is sizzling burning acid in my veins instead of blood.
    – I can’t barely walk anymore because of the neuropathy in my legs. It’s like there is an glowing campfire in my lower legs and if i walk like someone blows in the campfire. I can maximum walk 2 minutes and it’s painfull
    – Cold intolerance
    – Exhausted
    – Drug induced suicidal thoughts were extreme i fought for my life 8 months long to battle these thoughts. I won! These chemical induced insanity lessened slowly last months. But still suicidal everyday because of the insane distress i am in, now it are rational suicidal thoughts.
    – I can only lie on the sofa and suffer and lost literally everything

    It’s crazy that most people with cancer or in heroin withdrawal do better (sorry if I insult anyone but it’s truth, i said ‘Most’) while i used a legal drug as prescribed from a doctor.

    i am 30 years old and previously healthy and atletic
    I want to live badly! But I am now contemplating euthenasia with my doc. (Netherlands)

    Karma will find the people that are responsible (GSK)
    Thanks for reading

    • I read your post and I am so sorry that you are experiencing such pain. I know it’s very hard now, but things really do get better. It is an individual thing, but it does take a while or the body and the brain to shed the toxicity of these drugs. In fact, some have reported that it could take six to ten years to feel completely better. I fully stopped all my drugs in the spring of 2015. But, two years earlier, I almost died from these drugs when my brain/body was forced into a nearly comatose state. Howeer, it did take me two more years to extricate and free myself from psych world and the evil drugs and therapies, etc. I was, before all this, taking up eight drugs, including several antidpressants, an atypical anti-psychotic or two, a “benzo” and lithium. I can’t remember the exct name of each drug. Before that, they tried me on some many different drugs. I was a human guinea pig, a real live scientific experiment for the poster children of fraudalent science. But somehow I survived and I believe that you will, too. It is hard now but surviving this terror is worth the effort. Thank you.

      • I read a lot of people with insomnia, depression, suicidal thoughts an i surely believe this will heal over time. I surely had faith that the chemical induced Suicidal thoughts would fade away and it did after 8 months.

        But such severe neurological/physical problems with only 1 course of an SSRI and such short exposure. It feels like my body and nervous system is destroyed completely. Totally incapacitated and in severe pain every day. I never seen/read a ‘physical’ case like this heal (i searched a lot) that’s the reason why i lost hope and talking with my doc about A.S.

        Even if it takes someone 8 years to heal how to go on with life after such a catastrophe without contracting PTSD?

        Thanks for your message i appreciate

LEAVE A REPLY