I’m Done With Mental Health Providers

14
1449

Back in the early 2000s, my parents had me involuntarily hospitalized several times. I got the whole psychiatric smorgasbord: strapped to a gurney when I was perfectly able to walk, injected with medications against my will, spoken to slowly and loudly like I was incapacitated. I got the works, except for one hallmark experience of forcible treatment: I was never restrained because I didn’t do anything to endanger anyone. When people ask me why I didn’t kick or punch the nurse administering the shots, I don’t have a good answer. I’m just not good at violence.

The psychiatrists are, though. They never physically struck me — with all the damage they inflicted, they didn’t need to — but I saw one esteemed Yale shrink throw a red-haired woman onto a couch.

Because I criticized the system and I wouldn’t agree to debilitating regimens of medications, I was labeled as having no insight into my own illness. That’s worse than any diagnosis they can muster. To them, I was so ill that even the most severe psychiatric interventions would never help me. One famed Columbia doctor told my parents to abandon me, like leave me stranded there in New York, because I was terminally mentally ill.

He was just one example of psychiatry’s total divorce from the healing arts. One NYU psychiatrist left a message on my parents’ voicemail calling them “pieces of excrement” because they supposedly hadn’t paid his bill, only to call three minutes later to say in a pleasant lilt: “Never mind, I found the check.” Or the Fifth Avenue psychiatrist who wore women’s eyeglass frames (but not in that accidental and ironic way George Costanza did on Seinfeld) and told me I should become a firefighter because I had muscular thighs.

Cross-legged, I sat in front of Barnes and Noble’s psychology rack and picked out books by prominent critics of modern psychiatry whose titles told my story: Peter Breggin’s Your Drug May Be Your Problem, and Antipsychiatry: Quackery Squared, The Manufacture of Madness, and Psychiatric Slavery by Thomas Szasz.

The books confirmed what I had surmised. We’ve buried trauma with diagnostic codes. We’ve medicalized feeling too much or not enough. We’ve pathologized normal responses to abnormal situations. I refused to see any practitioner who worked within these constructs because they’re contrived, and designed to accomplish several goals that don’t include my health.

I refused, that is, until a jury convicted me of several crimes after a trial that has become a minor legend in the history of criminal justice in Connecticut, and I couldn’t stop crying. I went to a psychiatrist who wore a “Four More for Gore in 2004” political button on his jacket. It was 2007.

He wrote a prescription for Wellbutrin, a pill I had never been prescribed so its novelty intrigued me and goaded me into swallowing it. It didn’t make me less depressed; it gave me tiny seizures. But I did stop crying, and it put my ulcerative colitis into remission, an unexpected bonus.

I continued to take it throughout over six years in prison, meeting every six weeks with a psychiatrist who struggled with English, so conversation was a challenge and abuse either constant or impossible — the language barrier never let me know. When I left, a condition of the four years of probation awaiting me was that I had to get “mental health treatment as required.”

I dutifully surrendered myself to the Midwestern Connecticut Council on Alcoholism. I didn’t have a substance abuse disorder; MCCA treats low-income people, and I had nothing when I came home.

”I’m not doing group therapy or 12-step stuff. So I guess whatever you’re going to have to do to send me back [to prison], get it started now,” I told the intake worker. I was willing to do more time to avoid the psychiatric industrial complex.

Once they realized I was serious, they were floored, but they accommodated me, and found me individual therapists who made me skittish but at least I would only disappoint one person and not an entire room with my contrariness.

First was Cheryl. I really liked her but she was disciplined by the state for going furniture shopping with a client. I couldn’t tell from the licensing order if the furniture was meant for an abode that they would share, which would be a whole different kind of misconduct.

Then it was Rona, who was unproblematic. She winced every time she handed over a urine cup because she knew there was no risk of the sample coming back ‘dirty’ (containing illicit substances) but she was required to test me because of my probation. Rona then fled the organization, and Ted was assigned to me.

A licensed clinical social worker, Ted was 14 years my junior. But even for his lack of life experience, Ted seemed wise. He had already gone grey at 29 and I think I let that pass for wisdom. Like Rona, Ted offered to sign a statement for the court saying I was stable and didn’t need to come anymore, which was the kind of permission and clean bill of mental health that I had sought for over 15 years, in order to be released from a system that I found criminally oppressive. But I rejected it.

“No, let’s keep going.”

Ted diagnosed me with generalized anxiety disorder. At the time, I believed that he was helping me but that wasn’t why I stayed. I continued in therapy, not only at MCCA but following Ted to private practice, because the regular appointments flattered me that I was the right kind of ill — the approvable kind of ill, to interact with a system that had once rejected me. Telling people I was in therapy made me self-satisfied, even proud. No insight? Doctor, please! I have so much insight I double up on appointments. Remember: only healthy people know they’re sick.

I relied on Ted’s advice a lot. So much so that I let him lead me deeper into the mental health system. He convinced me to see a psychiatric nurse practitioner for my prescription; for five years prior my internist had written the scripts for me. But eventually, that nurse, Michael, reminded me of why I once recoiled at the mention of psychiatry.

“I think you should check into a hospital,” he said. “You’re going through a lot.”

Them’s fighting words for me and he knew that.

“That’s not the standard for hospitalization. I am not psychotic. I’m not even upset. No danger of hurting myself or others. What are you talking about?” I asked him. He didn’t have an answer.

I left the Zoom. Wait until I tell Ted, I thought. My trusted advisor.

But Ted was in lockstep. He explained that I could get respite from my stressors: the death of my father, and caretaking for my mother whose lung cancer recurred a week after his death.

“Okay, so what happens when the stressors don’t go away while I’m in this hospital? How would that help? You’re not making sense,” I said.

“So are you going to go?” he asked, like he didn’t know me or my history.

“You can bet your ass I’m not gonna go.”

“Okay, then. Goodbye.”

That was the last time I talked to Ted, after seven years of weekly sessions, over 350 hours of his guiding insight into myself; self-reflection that doctors had promised I would never have.

Months later I learned that Ted’s wife served him with divorce papers in an out-of-state rehab. Then I discovered online reviews of Michael describing him as the “worst experience of my life,” and realized that he and Ted were involved in pushing some useless app onto patients. Michael even responded to one patient’s negative review by describing the hallmarks of borderline personality disorder — an attempt at outing her diagnosis, a blatant HIPAA violation in my book.

I got my records from Michael and found notes on physical examinations he allegedly conducted on me. The blood pressure readings, the monitoring of my “gait” never happened, couldn’t have happened because my check-ins unfolded over Zoom meetings. He also wrote that I was studying for a CPA exam, a unique goal for someone convicted of financial crimes. To this day, I’m unsure whether he believes those notes are true or he knows they are complete fabrications.

Then I was in crisis, not psychiatric but epistemic. Have I developed discernment from an addict? Were my breakthroughs facilitated by someone who was drunk or high the whole time? Whose medical records are these? Why would anyone want to become an accountant?

I returned to rolling around in antipsychiatry except rather than a bookstore, this time it was Reddit threads; the world had shifted from books to social media since my last foray into antimedicalization. The experiences of those who’ve survived hospitalization, involuntary medication, expand and collapse in an accordion of comments that are almost conspiratorial. Sometimes they’re downright kooky.

And I agree with every last one of them.

Frankly, I’m a tad uneasy about siding with Scientologists and calling it sanity. Blaming psychiatry for the September 11 attacks is deranged — but so is bullying patients and calling it care. Maybe that’s the last trick the system plays on you: making the people it hurt seem too embarrassing to stand beside; a patient who doubts her own allies is a patient who keeps coming back.

That’s why I’m gone for good.

***

Mad in America hosts blogs by a diverse group of writers. These posts are designed to serve as a public forum for a discussion—broadly speaking—of psychiatry and its treatments. The opinions expressed are the writers’ own.

14 COMMENTS

  1. This very revealing and troubling account couldn’t help but remind me of a recent MIA article, “The Hidden Psychotherapy Drop-out Crisis.”
    It comes as no surprise to me that people seeking comfort and insight into their problems drop out of therapy after encountering the all too common type of smug, emotionally abusive, gas-lighting mental health “professionals” (some of them highly credentialed and experienced) described so vividly by Ms. Bozelko.
    The fact that clients abandon this artificial and unequal relationship is by no means a “crisis,” but an encouraging development and a sign of growing public awareness.

    Report comment

  2. Hi Chandra,

    you write;

    “Frankly, I’m a tad uneasy about siding with Scientologists and calling it sanity”.

    My attitude to Scientology is directed by what Muhammad Ali had to say about the Viet Cong and why he refused to go and kill their women and children……………. Because “No Viet Cong ever called me Ni&&er” They never lynched me, they never set no dogs on me, they never robbed me of my nationality …… *

    And it was a moment of enlightenment when I realised No Scientologist ever called me [insert slanderous psychiatric label here]. They’re not my enemy. My enemy is the mental health system. Scientologists don’t have the power to have me locked up because two people conspired to torture and kidnap. They can call me names but nothing like the slanderous labels applied by these ‘health professionals’.

    And how clever that these ‘professionals’ have managed to turn the title of Scientologist into a slanderous accusation?

    I like your article.

    *[Muhammad Ali – No Viet Cong Called Me N***er (1968) 1:10 on Youtube]

    Just a note for those who know me. They are about to open a locked facility (24 bed) with an ECT suite in the place where they “edited” the documented legal narrative for my lawyers (Ariel Castro Memorial Hospital). I am going to suggest to the Minister who will be cutting the red ribbon to fanfare some time soon that the place be called “Whistleblower House”…….. given the unstated aims and intended consequences of what is to be achieved there. The ‘experimental material’ to be handed over by the government for what will no doubt be called “groundbreaking research”.

    And we will watch while they send the grey buses for the ‘patients’ again?

    Report comment

  3. Patrick Clancy Wrongful Death Lawsuit Hearing

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-Zlr9oUUy3g

    It’s absolutely fascinating.

    I like the way the Americans go at it – really direct.

    There’s no affected English annunciation that edges upon creepiness heard in English legal cases that is full of class status with voice. I’d love to see an American like these two in an English court case blow it all – I’d say nonsense but it’s affected so many lives – out of the water.

    They are totally at it.

    Let’s hope it doesn’t get dismissed.

    Report comment

  4. Dear Chandra

    Afraid your experience of therapy chimes a little with my own. Six months ago today a therapist I had been attending for five years who had told me repeatedly she would never abandon me, that I had ‘no one’ and she ‘wanted to be there for me – dumped me unceremoniously when I informed her of my plan to get approved for an assisted death. She had known about this for three years and knew what was behind it (extremely abusive family dynamics and the possibility of homelessness). She didn’t just dump me – she lied her suicide policies and put the blame on me to my GP for not cooperating in the termination of the therapy. Since then I have not been able to leave the house more or less – I had finally let her in and trusted her. I have had 9 therapists – all did further psychological damage.

    Many were anti psychiatry. Of yes I went through psychiatry and all the multiple drugging and labelling and coercive treatment so I know all about that and it destroyed my chance of a life But the other cohort – the gang behind Drop the Disorder in the UK – the talking therapy will heal everything bullshitters – are just as bad. The whole mental health enterprise based as it is on either control or capital is the opposite of what healing should be. You cannot provide healing if it is conditional on the payment of money – that is the great lie that Freud willingly foisted on the world with his ‘I’ll have to go back now as some of my patients are beginning to get better’ most of them young women from affluent families who were being sexually abused.

    Report comment

  5. I’m in kinda similar position. Therapists and psychiatry hurt me many, many times and I don’t see the light at teh end of the tunnel of my own personal trauma prior to this and the “iatrogenic” trauma due to forced hospitalisation and medication. I feel my soul, and my connection to the human species has been permanently damaged due to these acts of torture. No one even understand this and more often than not, people deny that what I experienced was actually torture.
    I persisted and saw many other kind of therapists such as “trauma-informed” ones, but it did almsot nothing to me.
    So now I wonder how the author, and the other people who commented view their own future, how they live with their wounds day-to-day and if they lost hope for any healing to happen – without psychotherapists or psychiatrists, cause this burden and lack of hope to heal is almost unbearable to me.

    Report comment

    • “No one even understand this and more often than not, people deny that what I experienced was actually torture.”

      Article 1 of the Convention against the use of Torture states that torture;

      “does not include pain or suffering arising only from, inherent in or incidental to lawful sanctions.”

      Know how to access this caveat in the rules? Give someone the status of “patient”. In my State they simply “edit” the documented legal narrative after the fact and like magic, a citizen who was tortured becomes an “outpatient” and the torture is now ‘treatment’.

      I’m not sure if you can demonstrate that you were not a patient when these events occurred, but can I say even if you can you might want to keep it to yourself because where I live the response is to euthanise and have the Chief Psychiatrist utter with the fraudulent documents.

      Not a chance of anyone ever being held accountable when the State is full of organized criminals who are manufacturing reality to suit their desired ends.

      Report comment

      • Thank you for your response.
        I’m not sure if the law is similar here in France, but probably. I wish I could do something about what happened to me legally, but I don’t have the energy, partly because of the trauma these events caused me and partly because of what yo’ure stating.

        Report comment

    • Can comment in my own case. I have a close ‘relative’ who is a psychiatrist who was involved in the bad dynamic so there was really no escape at all. I was mistreated more than the other siblings in a very bad dynamic as a kid – not going into details.

      I vacillate between trying to accept that I am defective and should have complied fully with the psychiatric protocol and thinking that it was all lies. The truth is in the middle. Where I am from now anyway there is virtually no mental health system operating as the government do not fund it. If I wished to partake again of more psychiatric treatment the only options left to me as private online operations that charge vast sums of money for an assessment and follow up. It is such blatant profiteering and I have so little confidence in these people that I decided not to bother. I was in the public service for years which is not a service – just seeing a doctor in training every six month for 10 minutes – pure box ticking – no help with employment, social prescribing – anything at all really – just a questionnaire box check list.

      I can’t even most days form a clear picture of what happened to me – all the years of labelling and drugging and then having the labels changed abruptly – I have no clear idea anymore of my identity as a human being – the only one that fits now is person with serious mental illness. I don’t even know anymore about the validity of any of the labels – bipolar schizo affective, borderline, autistic that were handed out to me over the years.

      Every night where I live at 8.30pm approx I hear the horn of the train that used to ferry me every Tuesday when I was 24 years of age 100 miles away to another city where I would have to hang around all day to see Jungian analyst prescribed by the psychiatrist I was seeing at the time. Every time I saw this man he intimated to me that I was a hopeless case and every time I saw him he ate away at my sense that I was a person capable of surviving in the world. Every time I hear that train horn now I get triggered in a way that I never did in 30 years. I was young then and hopeful that I would be helped – otherwise I would not have subjected myself to that man – I do not understand mental health professionals almost complete lack of empathy for their patients/clients. This man was a psychologist -I found them the worst – far more callous than the psychiatrists.
      In any event, I continue to exist – I do not call it living anymore and I think that I barely lived at all. My solace was animals and nature but I face homelessness now and I have no one. That is why I arranged the assisted death from my savings. If I get to the homeless stage I will go ahead with that unless as looks increasingly likely there is a war in Europe and I can’t fly – that would be a real bummer.

      Report comment

      • “Where I am from now anyway there is virtually no mental health system operating as the government do not fund it.”

        I’m glad to hear such a place exists. A government that doesn’t see the benefits of a system that allows them to arbitrarily detain, torture and kill citizens with impunity? Where would such a place be?

        Report comment

        • When I saw virtually no mental health service operating I mean that the government do not fund it the same way that Reagan dismantled the asylums in the States – not because he cared but for financial gain.

          I heard today that 500 people died last year in this country while in mental health ‘care’ and 2,000 people were sectioned. I live in Ireland. We have half the EU average of psychiatrists. They have mental health units dotted around the country but all the big asylums are shut down.

          Report comment

  6. “I was willing to do more time to avoid the psychiatric industrial complex.”

    This is a very telling statement. I have never experienced prison myself, but I often joke that I’ve done time multiple times–in psych wards–and that I’m a felon for refusing to conform to the herd’s social standards and for thinking differently. I’ve also met people in hospitals who said they preferred their actual prison experience to the psych ward. It’s almost as if psychiatric patients have fewer rights than prisoners.

    I’m really sorry you went through this. It takes real strength to speak up for yourself in these moments. Congrats on exorcising yourself from the system!!

    Report comment

  7. More of us in Amerika, for starters, need to get mad like this. We live in a society of systemic abuse, and when bizzness as usual breaks us, more abuse is waiting to treat us for our ‘illness’. What a bunch of arrogant a–holes professional ‘service’ providers (whom we serve) are so often, arrogantly ignorant of any other way of seeing reality than the sectarian disciplines in which they’ve been indoctrinated, a–holes inflicting more suffering on others for no more reason than making money off patient prisoners while mindf—ing them all the more with humanitarian lies. Good riddance to these frauds.

    Report comment

LEAVE A REPLY