The Concerned Parents’ Project – March 23rd

So-called mental disorders are not “diagnosed” based on causes that can be tested for (or even articulated) but are instead “diagnosed” according to what are called symptom pictures. This is a highly questionable practice.


For example, what is the logic in calling defiance a “symptom of the mental disorder of oppositional defiant disorder”? Why isn’t it just defiance? Why is questioning rules a “symptom of the mental disorder of oppositional defiant disorder”? Why isn’t it just questioning rules? Why is “excessive arguing with adults” a “symptom of the mental disorder of oppositional defiant disorder”? Why isn’t is just arguing a lot (and maybe for good reason)? What justifies the leap from defiance, questioning rules, and arguing with adults to the pseudo-medical sounding mental disorder label “oppositional defiant disorder,” given that there is zero rationale for doing so?

You may be thinking, “Well, maybe the system is flawed, but surely psychiatrists, psychologists, family therapists and other mental health professionals know what to do with these symptom pictures. Maybe it isn’t exactly science but maybe it is an art, where, through practice, mental health professionals begin to discern the difference between a mental disorder and a life challenge. So, even though the system is flawed, no doubt practitioners do know important things about mental disorders.” You would be mistaken in that belief and that puts you in a very difficult position. If you can’t really trust the basic premises of psychiatry, what are you supposed to do? No one has perfect or even very good answers. But at least there are many things that you might try, from educating yourself about the pros and cons of so-called psychiatric medication to improving your parenting skills and reducing family stress to exploring alternative resources like peer counseling, mentoring, play therapy, and talk therapy. It is very hard on you that you can’t really trust mental health providers to know what they are doing, to have a solid rationale for what they are doing, or to be making claims based on solid science. Still you must persevere, even if no one you encounter is really the expert he or she claims to be.


Read the Concerned Parents’ Project Introductory Post

Read Question 22

To get in touch or to share your feedback, please email us

Read more on this topic

You, Your Kids, or the Doctor… Who’s Running the Show?

Interview: Does Psychiatry Actually Diagnose?

Visit Parent Resources for additional in-depth articles


Mad in America hosts blogs by a diverse group of writers. These posts are designed to serve as a public forum for a discussion—broadly speaking—of psychiatry and its treatments. The opinions expressed are the writers’ own.


Mad in America has made some changes to the commenting process. You no longer need to login or create an account on our site to comment. The only information needed is your name, email and comment text. Comments made with an account prior to this change will remain visible on the site.