Benzodiazepine Prescriptions in Older Adults Used in Rural and Low Income Areas

Benzodiazepine prescription practices may be in response to an epidemic of distress, rather than being used to treat specific mental health diagnoses.

Shannon Peters
10
649

A new study, led by Donovan Maust, geriatric psychiatrist, researcher, and assistant professor at the University of Michigan, investigates geographic and physician characteristics related to benzodiazepine prescribing in Medicare beneficiaries. The results of the study, published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, suggest that benzodiazepine prescriptions are more common in areas that are more rural and have lower income and education levels. Benzodiazepines were also more commonly prescribed by male providers. Additionally, areas that also had high rates of opioid prescribing were associated with higher rates of benzodiazepine prescribing.

“Given the potential adverse outcomes associated with their use—particularly in combination with opioids—it is important to consider whether this variation in BZD [benzodiazepine] prescribing may be contributing to the uneven distribution of gains in or even worsening of life expectancy in counties across the USA,” state the researchers.

Benzodiazepines can impair cognition and increase the risk of falls in older adults. The authors note, “the extent of BZD prescribing is high given the availability of safer, guideline-recommended treatments like selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors and cognitive behavioral therapy.” Only 5.6% of people prescribed benzodiazepines receive their prescription from psychiatrists, meaning the vast majority are prescribed in primary care. This is especially true for older adults as psychiatrists are less likely to accept Medicare compared to other specialties. The researchers discuss that benzodiazepine prescribing is usually done without a clear mental health diagnosis, and seek to understand how the geographic region or prescriber characteristics may affect benzodiazepine prescription practices.

“If mental health disorders are not fully driving BZD prescribing, more extensive BZD prescribing in socioeconomically distressed counties might suggest that this distress—rather than a clinical indication such as panic disorder—is driving potentially inappropriate prescribing,” state the authors.

The researchers reviewed the 2015 Medicare Part D Public Use Files, Area Health Resources Files, and County Health Rankings for information on prescription practices, patient demographics, and physician characteristics. The researchers calculated the intensity of benzodiazepine prescribing within a county based on the percentage of days that benzodiazepines were prescribed by the county’s primary care providers (PCP) out of the number of days that all Part D medications were prescribed. They also calculated the intensity at the PCP-level (i.e., the percentage of days benzodiazepines were prescribed out of total days of all Part D medication were prescribed by an individual PCP).

Results show, “Medicare Part D beneficiaries were dispensed over US$374 million worth and 1.2 billion total days of BZDs, which comprised 2.3% of all Part D medication days.” PCPs were responsible for 62% of all benzodiazepine prescriptions. States with the highest county-level prescribing practices were Louisiana, Florida, West Virginia, Tennessee, and Alabama.

Higher intensity counties were more rural and had fewer primary care providers and psychiatrists per capita. Counties in New York state had some of the lowest intensity prescribing practices for benzodiazepines, with all but three counties being in the lower quartile (i.e., the bottom 25% of counties). The authors highlight that New York initiated a strict benzodiazepine prescription policy 30 years ago, and suggest this policy explains the lower-intensity prescribing.

“In the final model, several other concerning county-level health status characteristics were associated with high-intensity BZD prescribing, including more days of poor mental health, a higher proportion of disability-eligible Medicare beneficiaries, and a higher suicide rate,” write the researchers.

At the PCP-level, female providers were less likely to be high-intensity prescribers. More years in practice was associated with higher intensity prescribing. Having more patients who are white or receiving low-income subsidies was also associated with higher intensity prescribing while having older patients was associated with lower intensity prescribing.

The most influential single factor associated with high-intensity benzodiazepine prescribing was also being a high-intensity opioid prescriber. The authors expressed concern for the possibility that some PCPs may be prescribing both benzodiazepines and opioids to the same patients but noted that they did not have access to patient-level data and therefore could not determine whether this was the case. Additionally, prescribing antibiotics and prescribing for the elderly at high intensity were associated with high-intensity benzodiazepine prescription practices.

The results are in line with previous research from Maust’s research team finding non-clinical factors contribute to long-term benzodiazepine use. The authors conclude,

“Because a large amount of BZD prescribing occurs without a mental health or insomnia diagnosis, our findings fit Case and Deaton’s hypothesis, with prescribing potentially in response to distress in socioeconomically disadvantaged counties.”

 

****

Maust, D. T., Lin, L. A., Blow, F. C., & Marcus, S. C. (2018). County and physician variation in benzodiazepine prescribing to Medicare beneficiaries by primary care physicians in the USA. Journal of General Internal Medicine33(12), 2180-2188. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-018-4670-9 (Link)

10 COMMENTS

    • Charles Walker, Conservative: “Mr Speaker can I thank my friend for her determined campaigning in the area of mental health.

      “Will she join me in congratulating Simon Wessely in his findings and even though this house is divided on so many issues, it should be united on this issue.”

      Theresa May replied: “How we look at mental health will unite people across this house and I congratulate the work done by Mr Wessely.

      “We will commit as a government to come forward with legislation in due course.”

      Thanks to Auntie Psychiatry for that!

  1. “the Mental Health Act takes away your liberty and imposes treatment that you don’t want. It can be traumatic, frightening and confusing. But on the other it can help restore health ”

    This is what struck me from Simon Wessely.

    Re: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/762206/MHA_reviewFINAL.pdf

    Does anyone here think psych drugs ‘help restore health’ ? I’ll grant one thing… a benzodiazepine can help calm a person in the short term.

    NOT until psychiatrists with power such as Simon Wessely admit that psych drugs are killer drugs indeed cause the very condtions that make people suicidal and violent (akathisia/toxic psychosis) will we see any really change in all this abuse.

  2. Fascinating map – somewhat similar to those showing opioid abuse, poor diet/obesity, loss of good rust belt jobs, high number of evangelicals, and so on.
    I wonder if the industries supporting the above (BigPharma/BigMac/Walmart, and so on) actually collude.