What If We Are All Wrong About Mental Illness?

1
From Thoughtful Living: The biomedical model of psychiatry, along with the DSM, is deeply flawed and can often be misleading. To improve, mental health services...

Researchers Question the Utility of an ADHD Diagnosis

16
A new article examines the usefulness of the ADHD diagnosis and suggests alternatives

10 Life Lessons I Learned as a Psychiatric Nurse and Patient

0
In this piece for Wake Up World, Cortland Pfeffer shares 10 life lessons he learned from his experience as a psychiatric patient, a recovering...

Study Explores Meanings of Bipolar Disorder to Those Diagnosed

11
The narratives about Bipolar Disorder promoted by drug companies may influence how those diagnosed understand themselves.

Difference is Not Disease: Scientific Integrity, Human Diversity, and the Potentially Bleak Future of...

173
There has been a lot of talk lately about neuroscience and the future of the medical model of "mental illness." It was made clear, in NIMH director Thomas Insel’s statement, that the DSM is a system of identification and classification of what are deemed disorders within our human experience. This isn’t exactly news to the vast majority of people who have spent even a little bit of time thinking about whether or not psychiatric diagnosis makes sense.

Beyond Critique: Psychologists Discuss Diagnostic Alternatives

2
The Journal of Humanistic Psychology compiles diverse research offering diagnostic alternatives toward a paradigm shift in mental health care.

The Concept of Schizophrenia is Coming to an End – Here’s Why

6
From The Conversation: Many researchers are beginning to acknowledge that the concept of "schizophrenia" as a discrete, hopeless, and deteriorating brain disease does not exist. In...

A Case Against Antidepressants

0
From Newsroom: University of Auckland researchers make a case against the chemical imbalance theory of mental illness, arguing that biological explanations and treatments for emotional...

Findings Linking Depression to Abnormal Brain Activity Questioned

6
Meta-analyses fail to replicate findings linking abnormal brain activity to depression.

An Eminent Psychiatrist Demurs on Trump’s Mental State

5
In this opinion piece for the New York Times, Allen Frances, chairman of the task force that wrote the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental...

Using Formulation to Change Team Cultures

6
I am returning to the subject of psychological formulation after rather a lengthy gap, during which controversy about the forthcoming 5th edition of DSM has continued to grow – sign the petition ‘Stop the Insanity’ at  www.dsm5response.com if you share others’ concerns about the creeping medicalisation of everyday life and the risks that it poses.

The Demoralized Mind

0
From openDemocracy: The distress, boredom, and disillusionment so commonly diagnosed as depression may actually result from the demoralization people experience in consumerist cultures. Large-scale cultural change,...

Sociologist Explores the DSM-5’s Failed Attempt at Validity

6
In a new article for the journal Social Science & Medicine, sociologist Owen Whooley investigates how the DSM-5 creators failed in their attempt to...

Does ‘Mental Illness’ Exist?

6
In this interview for ABC Australia, leading psychology professor Peter Kinderman discusses why we need alternative ways of understanding and supporting people in distress that take...

More Thinking about Alternatives to Psychiatric Diagnosis

14
In my last post, I argued that the single most damaging effect of psychiatric diagnosis is loss of meaning. By ruthlessly divesting experiences of their personal, social and cultural significance, diagnosis turns ‘people with problems’ into ‘patients with illnesses.’ Horrifying stories of trauma, abuse, discrimination and deprivation are sealed off behind a pseudo-medical label as the individual is launched on what is often a lifelong journey of disability, exclusion and despair.

The Chemical Imbalance Theory of Mental Disorders

5
In this video for AdvancingMentalHealth.org, Jeff Baker provides a detailed overview and critique of the chemical imbalance theory of mental illness.

Unanswered Questions in New Mental Health Screening Program for Children

17
An article presents new screening tools for pediatric depression and anxiety—but fails to answer its own questions about efficacy.

Hearing Voices Network Launches Debate on DSM-5 and Psychiatric Diagnoses

29
The recent furore surrounding publication of the new DSM has provided a much-needed opportunity to discuss and debate crucial issues about how we make sense of, and respond to, experiences of madness and distress. Many psychiatrists, psychologists and other mental health professionals have expressed their dismay about the dominance and inadequacy of a biomedical model of mental illness. Whilst we share these concerns, welcome these debates and support colleagues that are willing to take a stand, The Hearing Voices Network believes that people with lived experience of diagnosis must be at the heart of any discussions about alternatives to the current system.

Psychosocial Adversities Should be Included in Diagnosis

2
Proposal to include psychosocial adversities that impact mental health in ICD and DSM diagnoses.

Is Everything Johann Hari Knows About Depression Wrong?

2
In this piece for The Guardian, Dean Burnett critiques Johann Hari's new book challenging what we know about depression. According to Burnett, many of the points...

Is Mental Illness Real?

3
From The Guardian: Conceptualizing emotional distress or suffering as the result of a biological, genetic illness may be stigmatizing and inaccurate, and may lead to...

Scapegoating Persons Labelled Mentally Ill: The Politics of Marginalization

15
Scapegoating is an ancient human practice that probably dates from the time the first human beings decided to circle their huts -- what we fondly term the dawn of civilization. When things got tense in the compound, penalties got handed out to one or more individuals or families, those usually at the low end of the pole, the politically powerless or vulnerable.

Race and Class Affect Teacher Perceptions of ADHD Medication Use

2
Study uncovers teachers’ attitudes surrounding ADHD medication use and examines the influence of race and social class on teacher beliefs.

From Psychiatry and Psychotherapy’s Grand Delusion Toward Constructions of a Post-Therapeutic State

6
by Eugene Epstein, Manfred Wiesner, and Lothar Duda Over the past 50 years, the psychiatric and psychotherapeutic discourses of the western first world have infiltrated...

Study Reveals Inconsistency in ADHD Diagnostic Determinations

12
Researchers compare differences between research and clinical diagnoses of ADHD and explore the consistency of clinical determinations over time