“Survival of a Whistleblower.” On June 27, 2018, I gave an invited talk with this title at a meeting at the Max Planck Institute for Human Development in Berlin organized by directors Gerd Gigerenzer and Ralph Hertwig.
If I had known what was in store for me, the title would have been “Death of a Whistleblower.” I describe the problems I have had with the leadership of the organisation I co-founded 25 years ago, the Cochrane Collaboration, particularly in relation to my criticism of psychiatric drugs.
On September 13, the Cochrane Governing Board expelled me from the board and from Cochrane after a show trial and after Cochrane’s own hired lawyer had exonerated me of all charges raised against me (see the documents on Deadly Medicines and Organised Crime). It played a key role that my research team had criticised a Cochrane review of the HPV vaccines published in May 2018. Our criticism was highly warranted and strengthened a month later, in the same scientific journal, four days after my expulsion. It was considered very bad behaviour that I had criticised a Cochrane review although our own policy encourages this; we even have an annual prize for the best criticism. This is outright scientific censorship, which is highly damaging to any scientific enterprise, as also described by Bob Whitaker recently.
Back home in Denmark, my hospital announced that I would be fired, for no good reason. It seems to be a political firing coming from the Ministry of Health, which has paid no attention to the fact that I have saved Danish taxpayers billions of crowns though my research; have created a research centre of international repute; and that the patients appreciate my initiatives. Now the time had come to silence a vocal critic of the drug industry, psychiatry and the establishment.
I am just the messenger, the symbol that healthcare is in many ways absurd and harmful because the drug industry is too powerful. The Cochrane Collaboration is in deep crisis because it is too close to industry, practices scientific censorship and has a business model that focuses on “brand” and “our product,” rather than open scientific debate or getting the science right, even though a few people might become upset by being told that their work wasn’t good enough.
Below is my whistleblower talk. In it I discuss how Peter Rost’s book The Whistleblower: Confessions of a Healthcare Hitman described the fate of 233 people who blew the whistle on fraud in the healthcare system: 90% were fired or demoted, 27% faced lawsuits, 26% had to seek psychiatric or physical care, 25% suffered alcohol abuse, 17% lost their homes, 15% got divorced, 10% attempted suicide and 8% went bankrupt. But in spite of all this, only 16% said that they wouldn’t blow the whistle again.
I also share my view, as a biologist, that a “hero” is someone who has different genes than non-heroes. During evolution, it’s an advantage to stay in the middle rather than being a hero, so that you have less risk of dying. But then there are a few odd people who have something else in our genes, where we don’t really think much about the risk for ourselves, we just do what we think is right despite the risk. So how did these genes survive during evolution? I think it’s because when a tribe comes under threat, grave danger, the people in the middle don’t know what to do. But then those with these special genes take over and become leaders. And then you might get through the crisis.
Um, I was right with you until you got in to the genetics (eugenics?) part at the end. Is courage genetically determiined?
Regardless, thanks for accepting the difficult role you have been assigned by the Universe of messenger/martyr, I don’t envy you. I hope what you are undergoing is worthwhile and useful in widely exposing the totalitarianism and deception inherent in pharmaceutical propaganda/marketing.
I noticed something else:
It played a key role that my research team had criticised a Cochrane review of the HPV vaccines published in May 2018.
Let me guess — Cochrane gave the green light to these vaccines and you challenged that? Because the hysteria directed at those who oppose the mass “vaccination” of children rivals that slung at those who oppose psychiatric drugging. In addition naturopathic and other healers have been mysteriously dying and disappearing for years, with the common factor seemingly their research into the dangers of vaccines. So be careful.
Report comment
I have a little problem with this “special gene” theory as well. It reminds me of “the great man theory”. Alexander earns the moniker “the great” through a hostile take over of all these independent nations. Julius Caesar comes along, and says, “that means there are people specially endowed to rule the world. People like me.” Caesar gets his just deserts, but the empire rolls on, until the barbarians anyway. Napoleon comes along, and says, “The revolution is over! Hail, the new emperor!” Traditional monarchies object, and take him down. Hitler comes along, and says, “I’m the man particularly endowed to rule all the nations of the world.” Anybody sense a pattern here?
Report comment
You don’t need great genes to be a hero. 🙂
Report comment
I Think The HPV Vaccine is too Large and International to be Questioned.
Report comment
Hello Peter,
what are your plans for the future?
The outrage of the main ‘industry’, protecting their business interests means that psychiatric survivors are watching you with great interest.
Report comment
You are a hero as far as I am concerned. I have seen you toss paper aside during debates when you become frustrated by ignorance, and you can be abrasive, but so what? When you have ethics and integrity, you irritate those who don’t. Loved a scripted dialogue scenario exchange you did with Olga on anti-sex pills, the “anti-depressants” in a you tube video on a conference u spoke at.
You are correct about it all- the harms of the psychiatric drugs, mammograms, and this particular vaccine. You are pissing off dangerous people with no humanity or decency, so watch out for yourself.
I hope Cochrane can be purged of corruption and regain its original focus.
You are a whistleblower who deserves to be reinstated- it is obvious that something is not right when half the board resigned in solidarity with you.
Without people like you, Robert Whitaker, and a few others like John Read and Nial McLaren who are passionate about the truth and well being of human beings everywhere, the evil forces of psychiatry and pharma would have free reign. Good luck in all you do.
Report comment
Thank you for your community service; I am sorry that it is causing you hardship.
I am also a biologist and disagree with your belief that biology can address a philosophy (a philosophical concept of a “hero”); “evolutionary psychology” is too abstract to pass for biology.
Report comment
Heros have different souls.
Report comment
http://www.google.com/search?q=holistic+doctors+killed
The clip art for this article is appropriate. The world wide medical mafia doesn’t play. And did they find Jamal Khashoggi’s body yet? Bet that dude was going to blow the whistle on Sept 11.
Report comment
Will we have a chance to commemorate one day the tomb of the Unknown Disabled Employee or will we all die on this planet because of an unknown genetical pandemic ? Should I ask about this question to Mr. Juwang Zhu ?
Report comment
Can you do a brutal ladder, Peter? Was Hitler able to do it? If not, that means you are genetically lazy.
Nazis fixation over body and genetics do not concerned their main leaders…. I am not saying you are Hitler, but it is very primitive and rude to submit biology and genetics over INDIVIDUAL PSYCHOLOGICAL ARCHETYPE.
There are many kinds of heroism. One of them is being trapped in psychological reality beyond your control. It so easy to be a hero in apollonian state of psyche. Their psychological archetype, their easiness is almost stupid. From psychological perspective death is the truth and apollonians, and those who called themselves healthy, are crazy utopians.
When your ego is being shaterred you are becoming a hero of psychological descent. Spiritual fascists do not give a damn that they are in the simplest psychological archetype. And they think that lack of ability to see gives them a right to judge.
Do you think, Rockefeller was there? Or Ghandi? Or maybe Jesus? Do you think that famous, shallow people were in that reality? No.
Spiritualists and apollonians completely forget about psychological reality.
There are heroes of descent. Apollonians as the least psychological, are the greatest heroes…… of psychological blindness.
Strict psychological realty can kill you, like it kills Anneliese Michel and many more also rejected by church and condemned by psychiatry, because psychiatry does not believe in psyche. PSYCHIATRY BELIEVES IN SATAN.
“Re-visioning psychology” James Hillman.
Manufacture of madness – Szasz
Read it Peter, because you are nice.
Report comment
The fact that normal or apollonians can not touch the death reality/psychological reality, does not mean that it does not exists.
There are people with natural ability to be slim. And they want medals for that fact. Well, it is not an achievement, it is a trait.
Report comment
You should see photos and clips of Josef Goebbels, spokesman for the master race. He was short, dark and club-footed. He went through life singing the praises of the alleged Master Race, while doing his best to stay out of sight. Naturally he killed himself, his wife and kids when he realized his Russian/Slavic inferiors were going to take Berlin (they were overrunning the city, going wild) and nothing could stop them.
Report comment
Hope you start again and continue, you have very many followers who support your work. But also agree with oldhead… be careful.
Report comment
I knew there was something wrong with Cochrane when they gave a neutral to favorable assessment of Aricept/donepezil, a highly destructive drug given to old people with memory problems. I’d read enough and seen enough to know it is a terrible drug. Of course all the published trials show a moderate positive effect. But if you can find studies where it is used as an active placebo in the trial of a newer drug, or when subjects in new drug trials who were already taking it are allowed to continue taking it, you’ll see that they decline faster than people who don’t take it. A study supporting the above has just been published. https://www.practiceupdate.com/content/association-of-concomitant-use-of-cholinesterase-inhibitors-or-memantine-with-cognitive-decline-in-clinical-trials-of-alzheimers-disease/75573
Cochrane giving it a thumbs up was very, very wrong.
Report comment
Hi BL — I urgently need info about aricept — do you have the same email? (I’ll try it.)
Report comment
From the original tale by Hans Christian Andersen… “The Procession Must Go On!” (And so it does.)
“But the Emperor has nothing at all on!” said a little child.
“Listen to the voice of innocence!” exclaimed his father; and what the child had said was whispered from one to another.
“But he has nothing at all on!” at last cried out all the people. The Emperor was vexed, for he knew that the people were right; but he thought the procession must go on now! And the lords of the bedchamber took greater pains than ever, to appear holding up a train, although, in reality, there was no train to hold.
http://www.online-literature.com/hans_christian_andersen/967/
Report comment
Thank you, Peter, for all you have done for those who are being threatened with death and injury through the legalized drug trade.
This age, particularly hard in its whistle blowers, hopefully will be succeeded by another. What is the problem? Obviously, greed, immorality, and corruption. (If everybody wants to be a member of the 1 %, you’ve got nobody to apply the reins to the 1 %, and to hold the 1 % in check per se.) You let people get away with murder, and there’s no end to it, unless we call an end to it. The drug companies in league with the mental illness industry have been killing people with abandon for some time now.
What is needed? I don’t know. Maybe a Whistle Blowers Union that could take on corruption in general.
Report comment
I like that! Let’s get it going. “WBU local #147 annual meeting will come to order.”
Report comment
I reckon the “Hero gene” is just being a Leader – you naturally want to protect the tribe at great risk to yourself. That serves a genetic purpose, as well.
Thank you for all you do. When I saw you speak in Australia a few years back, I wondered how it was possible that you were employed, prestigious, and that the Cochrane Collaboration was the last bastion of objective science in medicine.
Sadly, that is past tense now. I trust your work, but Cochrane no longer. You will always find a place to fully utilise your great gifts of diligent, clear thinking, precise language, and passion for humanity.
Report comment
Dear Dr Peter,
I follow your articles with relish.
Somebody has to say something because “medicine” is genuinely falling apart.
I can’t help feeling though, that you’re in a better place on the outside than on the inside.
Report comment
Thank you for speaking out about the fraud and lies of psychiatry, Dr. Gøtzsche. It’s a shame those who speak the truth are being attacked.
Report comment
Very informative talk on whistleblowers and a most fitting quote from Desmond Tutu.
It is pernicious when people in positions of trust stay neutral to protect their own interests, turning a blind eye to lies, corruption, censorship and harm inflicted on others It takes great strength of character, morals and courage to stand up for your convictions and do what is right and honest. Thank you for being a crusader for justice and truth. The world desperately needs more like you Peter! Wishing you much success in your battle.
Report comment
Hi Peter,
I saw you and Robert talk in Christchurch New Zealand earlier this year and it was a great privilege to be able to after following your work over the last 5 years. You both really opened my eyes to what I had been taught, resulting in me only using psychotropic drugs when I really need them as opposed to every day.
I hope that all of this will make you even stronger in your resolve to continue to expose the truth. You have supporters all around the world. In my eyes you are a hero as I know personally I am always conscious about what I say in order to not bite off the hand that feds me, especially when I lack the scientific skill to do so in such an objective way that you do. But I do use your material and other material to point out to as many people as I am able to see the truth. We, the world, psychiatric survivors we all need you and more like you. So we can go back to a humane health system that is about people not profits.
Wishing you the best in your future journey as you continue to fight off the corporate greedy, drug pushing monsters.
Report comment
It happens on every level of society. Everyone has the potentional to take the hero’s journey. More than genetic, I would say it is a fact of soul evolution.
Report comment
The evolution of the soul will be, when everyone starts reading Hillman and will defend SOUL and phenomenology against psychopathic tentacles of pseudo science. When we are perceived only as genetic biological beings, we will remain only meat – healthy or not healthy. We are perceived as soulless meat and this should offends us.
We must fight for soul, to bring it back to our world. Hillman was trying.He left us his books.
The soul – mythic reality, phenomenology of the psyche are main reasons why I believe that hostile and anti psychological system of deceitful materialists (eg.psychiatry) can not last forever.
http://www.terrapsych.com/hillman.html
Report comment
Thanks for all you have done Peter. You have helped more people than you realize. You are a real hero to me!
Report comment
Great actions make a hero. Not great genes.
A lot of heroes are little, ordinary people who rise to the occasion. Often fearfully and reluctantly. But it’s the right thing…and someone’s got to do it!
Report comment
Btw, Dr. Goetzhe I consider you a hero, but it’s because you stuck your neck out for the voiceless though you probably knew something like this might happen. Actions not biology.
Report comment
Beautiful text but I tried to contact you several times without replies so even though you present yourself as a doctor and biologist you are not the one people can count on when they have problems, right?
Psychiatrists who support a critical view HIDE their names and it is impossible to find them. Where do you get help?
My conclusion is that doctors are not demons, unless they are using any kind of forced or violent treatment. Usually, they are just trying their best the way they were taught to help the dozens of people they meet every day to get out of their suffering and miserable lives and combine that with their own problems. At least, I hope.
In Brazil we still have madhouses with forced manipulation for law offenders but I guess prisoners are subjected to all kinds of experiments pretty much everywhere. And if you have a bad family, bad luck for you. You can be forcibly admitted and injected too.
Meanwhile, big pharma commits fraud and gets away with it, good for business, it’s an ironic world. They will say the delinquent is the poor boy with no food to eat selling marijuana at the favela.
I don’t know about vaccines but I have my personal sorrow with psychiatry which doesn’t stop me from empathizing with the one who has life and death on his hands, dealing with suicidals, etc. Not an easy job for sure.
In the end, I believe in the same as you: free science and listening to patients so that health care can improve and people no longer enter with a so called mental problem and die from a physical condition.
No matter how much I was harmed by antipsychotics and other legal heavy drugs, I have no feeling of revenge. I only want to help to improve.
I am sorry you were dismissed from Cochrane. I wish people learnt some democracy and debated civilized what they agreed with and what they didn’t. If their intention was to diminish your name, look at how many people calling you a hero.
Easy to be only critics. What do you do when someone can’t sleep out of anxiety, don’t eat thinking they are being poisoned and is seriously disturbed by whatever distress?
I asked for help from MadinBrasil in the past and got NONE. No return from anyone whatsoever. Easy to just blame others.
Report comment
No sorrow from MadinBrasil, critical doctors, regular doctors or anyone. Just trying to be fair and see how everyone is hopefully trying their best in their own circumstances.
And if I mistaken please correct me because this is all that happened and didn’t happen if you know what I mean.
Report comment